Christmas

← Encyclopedia

Christmas is the Christian feast commemorating the birth of Jesus, observed in most of the Western church on December 25 and across much of the Eastern church on January 7, where older calendars still govern the date. It is among the central celebrations of the liturgical year, and one of the few whose origins the tradition itself never recorded.

The Gospels supply the story without the date. Matthew and Luke narrate the Nativity — the manger, the shepherds, the magi — but neither names a day, nor a season, nor a year that the rest of the evidence can pin down. For the first Christian centuries the birth went largely unmarked; what the earliest churches kept was Easter. December 25 surfaces as a feast only in the fourth century. The oldest secure witness is a Roman almanac of 354, which records the Nativity kept on that day, and within a few generations the observance had spread through the Latin West and, with its own dates and emphases, the Greek East.

Why December 25 was chosen has been argued for more than a century, and the scholarship has not fully settled the question. The older and still widely repeated account is borrowing: that the church laid its feast over the winter solstice and the cult of Sol Invictus, the Unconquered Sun, which the emperor Aurelian instituted in 274 — though the December 25 solar date itself is attested chiefly by that same fourth-century almanac — absorbing a popular solar holiday and recasting Christ as the true light. A competing account, the calculation hypothesis, holds that the date was reasoned rather than borrowed: from an early tradition placing the crucifixion on March 25, and a notion that a perfect life filled an exact number of years, the same date was assigned to the conception — nine months before December 25. The evidence is read both ways; the solar context is real, and the internal Christian reckoning is real, and which carried the most weight remains genuinely contested.

What the feast came to hold is clearer than how its date was chosen. For the tradition, Christmas marks the Incarnation — the claim that the divine entered the world as an infant, the abstraction of theology made flesh in a particular child of a particular mother. The Eastern churches long bound the Nativity together with Epiphany and the baptism, festivals of divine appearing; the West drew them apart and built Christmas into a season of its own, with Advent before and the twelve days after. Across both, the older solar imagery was never quite discarded so much as turned: the shortest day, the light returning, read now as sign rather than rival.

The customs accreted later and locally — the midwinter greenery, the gift-giving, the carols and the tree — much of it medieval or modern, much of it absorbed from the seasons it overlay rather than handed down from the first churches. The feast that anchors them is older than its trimmings and younger than the event it keeps, a date the tradition chose long after the fact and has observed ever since as though it had always been so.

→ In the library: Steiner — Christianity as Mystical Fact (1910)

→ Related: Christianity · Bible · New Testament · Mary · Byzantine Empire