Philipp Jakob Spener

← Encyclopedia

Philipp Jakob Spener (1635–1705) was the German Lutheran theologian usually named as the father of Pietism, the renewal movement that pressed for a Christianity of felt inward devotion rather than doctrinal correctness alone. Born in Alsace and trained in the strict scholastic Lutheranism of his day, he came to think that the established church had won its arguments and lost its warmth — orthodox in its confessions, cold in its congregations.

The turning point came in Frankfurt, where Spener was senior minister. Around 1670 he began gathering small groups in his house to read scripture, pray, and speak about the conduct of the Christian life — the collegia pietatis, the “colleges of piety” that gave the movement one of its names. In 1675 he wrote a preface for a new edition of the sermons of the earlier devotional writer Johann Arndt; expanded and published on its own, it became the Pia Desideria, or “Pious Desires,” the closest thing Pietism has to a founding document. In it he diagnosed the ailments of the church and set out proposals: more and more serious engagement with the Bible by laypeople, the exercise of the “spiritual priesthood” of all believers, a Christianity practiced and not merely debated, gentler training of preachers, preaching aimed at the heart. The hope running through it was that the Reformation had reformed doctrine but not yet the life that doctrine was meant to produce.

Spener held that conversion should be a felt rebirth and that knowledge of God worth the name showed itself in changed conduct — claims his orthodox opponents heard as a slide toward subjectivism and works-righteousness, and as a threat to the church’s settled order. The household gatherings drew particular suspicion; critics warned that meetings outside the pulpit’s oversight bred separatism, and some of them did. Spener spent his later years in Dresden, then in Berlin under the protection of the Brandenburg court, defending the movement against charges of heterodoxy while it spread through the German territories.

Historians treat Pietism as one of the decisive forces in early modern Protestantism, and Spener’s reach extended past his own lifetime: his younger ally August Hermann Francke built the movement’s institutional center at Halle, with its schools, orphanage, and missionary and publishing enterprises, and the Pietist emphasis on personal experience left its mark on later evangelical revival, on Methodism through the Moravian channel, and, by reaction, on the Enlightenment that grew up beside it. The recurring scholarly question is how much of this Spener intended. He wrote as a reformer who meant to renew the Lutheran church from within, not to leave it; what he set in motion outran the modest house meetings where it began.

→ Related: Pietism · John Wesley · Grace In Christianity