Pietism

← Encyclopedia

Pietism is the renewal movement that arose within German Lutheranism in the later seventeenth century, holding that true Christianity is a matter of the reborn heart and a transformed life rather than of correct doctrine alone. It took shape as a protest from inside the church, not against it — a complaint that the faith had hardened into orthodoxy without warmth.

The movement is usually dated from 1675, when the Frankfurt pastor Philipp Jakob Spener published Pia Desideria — “Pious Desires” — a short program for reform. Spener argued that the Reformation had settled its doctrine but not yet reformed its people, and he proposed remedies that became the movement’s signature: small gatherings for Scripture and mutual encouragement, a renewed lay priesthood, preaching aimed at the conscience rather than at controversy. The word Pietist began as a jeer from opponents who distrusted these private meetings; it stuck, and the people it named eventually wore it without embarrassment.

What the Pietists taught was a sequence of the inner life. Genuine faith, they held, passed through a felt repentance and a rebirth — the new birth, the conversion that turned a nominal Christian into a living one — and showed itself afterward in sober conduct, charity, and the disciplines of prayer and reading. Doctrine they did not reject; they subordinated it. Right belief without an altered heart they regarded as dead. Spener’s successor August Hermann Francke built this conviction into institutions at Halle — an orphanage, schools, a press, a center for missions — making piety not only a private temper but a machinery of works. A separate strand, gathered by Count Zinzendorf at Herrnhut, became the Moravian Church, whose missionaries carried the movement far beyond Germany.

Historians treat Pietism as one of the formative forces of modern Protestant religion, and trace its reach well past its own borders. Its accent on personal conversion and heartfelt assurance shaped the evangelical awakenings of the English-speaking world; John Wesley’s encounter with Moravians is a documented turning point in the rise of Methodism. Its inward turn, scholars have long suggested, also fed the wider eighteenth-century interest in feeling and the self that surfaces in Romanticism — a resemblance worth marking, though the movement understood itself in strictly Christian terms and would not have recognized the secular uses later made of its language.

The lasting tension in Pietism is the one it began with. By relocating the center of faith from the church’s teaching to the believer’s experience, it gave Protestant Christianity much of its later emotional vocabulary; by the same move, it opened the long question — pressed by its critics from the start, and unsettled still — of how an inward and personal religion holds itself to any shared and public truth.

→ Related: Religion · Scholasticism