Paschal Beverly Randolph

← Encyclopedia

The word he chose for himself was a command. Across the title pages he printed under the name “The Rosicrucian,” and carved at last on the emblem that traveled with his order — a winged globe rising over an Egyptian horizon — stood a single imperative: Try. It was the motto of a man who had taught himself to read in the streets of New York’s Five Points, who went to sea at adolescence to keep from starving, and who would die at forty-nine in a white neighborhood of Toledo with a self-inflicted wound to the head. Between those two facts lies one of the strangest and most consequential careers in nineteenth-century esotericism: the first man to put sexual union at the doctrinal center of Western magic, and the first African-American to found a Rosicrucian order on American soil.

Paschal Beverly Randolph (1825–1875), physician, Spiritualist, and founder of the first American Rosicrucian order — via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

A self-made seer

Paschal Beverly Randolph was born in New York City on October 8, 1825. His mother, Flora Beverly, he later described as a woman of mixed English, French, German, Native American, and African ancestry; his father he claimed, on disputed authority, as a relation of the Virginia Randolphs. The genealogy mattered to him his whole life, and he returned to it obsessively — a man of color in a slaveholding republic, asserting and re-asserting a lineage that the country was organized to deny. When his mother died he was orphaned into the poverty of the Five Points, the most notorious slum in the country. He had almost no formal schooling. What he knew, he assembled himself, from sailors’ talk, from the cheap press, and from the lecture halls of a movement then sweeping the United States.

That movement was Spiritualism. By his mid-twenties Randolph had found a place in it as a trance medium, taking the platform to speak with the voices of the dead before paying audiences. It was a respectable enough entry point for a self-educated man with a gift for performance and a hunger for the invisible. But Randolph’s restlessness ran past the séance. The standard Spiritualist drama — passive sitters, a passive medium, spirits who arrive of their own accord — left him dissatisfied. He wanted a method one could work: a discipline of the will that produced results rather than waiting on them. The break, when it came, was sharp. In a series of pamphlets and lectures he repudiated mainstream Spiritualism’s passivity, warning that the open, receptive medium was prey to influences better left unsummoned, and turned toward what he came to call practical occultism — a phrase that, in his hands, meant something a man did with his own faculties, not something done to him.

The quarrel with Spiritualism was, for Randolph, the hinge of his whole development, and it is worth dwelling on its terms. The movement that had given him a platform rested on a model of reception: the medium emptied herself, and the dead — or whatever announced itself as the dead — spoke through the vacancy. Randolph came to regard that emptiness as a danger and a delusion. The undisciplined sitter, he warned, had no way to know what she had admitted; the trance state he had himself performed for pay was, on his later reckoning, an open door to influences neither benign nor honest. Against the passive medium he set the trained operator — a person who did not surrender the will but tempered and aimed it. The shift looks small and is total. It moves the locus of power from the visiting spirit to the living human being, and it converts a parlor entertainment into a discipline. Nearly everything Randolph built afterward follows from that one reversal.

The raw materials for that turn he claimed to have gathered abroad. Across the 1850s Randolph made solitary journeys through England, France, Egypt, and the Ottoman lands — to Paris, and from there, by his own account, to Egypt, Tunis, Arabia, and Syria. He returned from the Continent and the Near East in March 1858 carrying, he said, three things that would remake American occultism: the use of the magic mirror for clairvoyance, the controlled use of hashish as an aid to vision, and, above all, a doctrine of sex. According to his own telling, he had been initiated into Eastern brotherhoods of adepts — Rosicrucian and Ansairetic — who held the deepest of these teachings in trust. The historian John Patrick Deveney, whose 1997 biography remains the foundational scholarly account, treats these initiation narratives with care: the journeys were real, the contacts plausible, but the elaborate genealogy of unbroken Oriental fraternities is best read as the self-mythology by which a brilliant autodidact authorized teachings he had largely synthesized himself.

The first American Rosicrucian

In 1858 Randolph gave his synthesis an institution. Having long signed his occult writings simply “The Rosicrucian,” he founded the body later known as the Fraternitas Rosae Crucis, with a first Temple of Rosicrucia under his patronage — the organization usually called the first Rosicrucian order established in the United States. The judgment is not only that of his admirers. Arthur Edward Waite, the English occultist and historian who was rarely generous to rivals or predecessors, allowed that Randolph had founded the earliest known Rosicrucian order in America, and that assessment has carried through the scholarship since.

Rosicrucianism gave Randolph an idiom rather than a pedigree. The seventeenth-century manifestos that launched the legend of Christian Rosenkreutz described an invisible college of physician-adepts, healers who moved unrecognized through the world; for a self-taught Black doctor selling clairvoyant cures and patent elixirs, the figure of the hidden Rosicrucian physician fit like a glove. He took the name and the rose-and-cross imagery and poured into them a content the Renaissance manifestos never held. What Randolph meant by Rosicrucianism was not a Protestant reformation of learning but a working art of the generative force — the magical tradition he believed the West had lost and the East had kept.

Through the same years he poured out an extraordinary stream of books. Dealings with the Dead (1861–62) framed an occult cosmology in the voice of a disembodied narrator. Pre-Adamite Man (1863) argued, against the racial science of the day, for the antiquity and dignity of the non-white peoples of the earth — a work of esoteric anthropology serving a plainly political end. The Wonderful Story of Ravalette (1863), one of the earliest novels published by an African-American, dramatized his doctrines as fiction; in it the magic mirror, reincarnation, and the iron discipline of the will carry the plot. Seership! (1868) set out his system of the magnetic mirror. After Death; or, Disembodied Man mapped the soul’s posthumous itinerary. Across all of them runs a single conviction stated again and again: the human will, properly trained and properly aimed, is a real force in the world — and the deepest reservoir of that force is sexual.

Front cover of Eulis! The History of Love (1874), the work Randolph counted his highest revelation — via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

The generative force

Randolph’s distinctive teaching can be stated in one sentence, though he took thousands of pages to surround it: the energy released in the sexual embrace is the most concentrated form of magical power available to a human being, and the moment of mutual orgasm is the supreme moment of the soul’s openness to creation. Everything else in his system — the mirror, the will-disciplines, the Rosicrucian framing — orbits that center.

He gave the operative doctrine its clearest form in Eulis! (1874), the “history of love” he counted his third and highest revelation, and in privately circulated manuscripts that he would not commit to the open press: The Ansairetic Mystery and The Mysteries of Eulis. The core claim, stated within his own frame, is that at the instant of true and mutual climax the soul stands momentarily ajar to the spiritual world, and whatever is willed at that instant — willed with a love he insisted must be pure, reciprocal, and reverent — is impressed upon the forces of nature and tends to come to pass. Sex, for Randolph, was not indulgence licensed by mysticism; it was a sacrament with a technique, and a technique with a stern ethic. He held that a union without genuine mutual love was not merely a moral failure but a magical one — a discharge of the generative force into nothing, or worse.

Title page of Eulis! (1874), in which Randolph set out his operative doctrine of sexual magic — via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

Around this center he built a private vocabulary, the marks of a man constructing a science. Volantia named the calm, sustained, non-straining act of will by which the mind holds an image steady; decretism, the focused decree or command of the will toward an end; posism, the receptive posture by which the operator opens to the desired influence. These were the disciplines of the magus as Randolph conceived him — not the ceremonial apparatus of robes and circles that the next generation of ritual magicians would elaborate, but interior operations of attention and desire, of which the sexual rite was the most powerful instance. His occultism descended from the animal-magnetism tradition of trance and magnetic rapport as much as from anything Rosicrucian; the magnetic mirror, the cultivated will, the operator who alters reality by force of concentrated mind — all bear the stamp of mesmerism turned toward magical ends.

Symbolic frontispiece from Eulis! (1874), one of the emblematic plates Randolph used to figure his doctrine — via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

The secrecy around the deepest material was deliberate and, by Randolph’s lights, protective. He drew a sharp line between what could be printed and what could only be entrusted by hand. Eulis! circulated openly enough to draw prosecutors; The Ansairetic Mystery and The Mysteries of Eulis he kept to a private cadre, copied and passed under conditions of confidence. The reticence was not coyness but a conviction about the matter itself: a force this concentrated, in his account, could wound the careless as readily as it could elevate the prepared, and the ethic of mutual love that he made the precondition of any working was meant as a safeguard as much as a sanctification. He framed the whole as a graded revelation — Eulis! the third and highest of his disclosures of “soul and sex” — so that the public reader received the philosophy while the operative key stayed with those he judged ready for it.

It is worth marking how alone this teaching stood. The occult revival of the later nineteenth century would treat sex with embarrassed silence or outright horror; the respectable esoteric societies sublimated it, allegorized it, or forbade discussion of it. Randolph, decades before Aleister Crowley made sexual magic notorious and decades before the clinical sexology of the new century, said plainly that the act was the engine. He paid for the candor. He was prosecuted on obscenity charges, hounded in the Spiritualist press, and dogged by the suspicion that the doctor selling love-philters and erotic mysteries was simply a charlatan with a higher vocabulary.

Abolition, Reconstruction, and a contested death

Randolph never separated the inner work from the world. Like many Spiritualists, he lectured for the abolition of slavery; unlike most, he had the standing of a Black man speaking to white audiences about a system built on the bodies of people like his mother. During the Civil War he took a leading part in recruiting Black soldiers for the Union army. After emancipation he went south to Louisiana and taught literacy to the freedpeople of New Orleans, carrying the same imperative — try — into the Reconstruction schoolroom. The man who taught that the will could remake reality meant it as politics as well as magic. Pre-Adamite Man, with its argument for the ancient nobility of the darker races, belongs to the same project: an esoteric refutation of the racial hierarchy that organized his country.

The strain told. Randolph spent his life checked — by poverty, by prosecution, by the color line, by the chronic depressions he wrote about with unusual frankness. On July 29, 1875, in a white district of Toledo, Ohio, he died of a wound to the head. The contemporary verdict, reported in the Toledo press under the headline “By His Own Hand,” recorded it as suicide, and the documentary record carries it as such; he was forty-nine. The death has not stayed settled. Some who knew him found the suicide hard to reconcile with a man who had written against self-destruction, and a later head of his order, R. Swinburne Clymer, reported a deathbed confession by which an acquaintance, in a fit of jealousy, claimed to have killed him — an account the surviving evidence cannot confirm. Probate records, for their part, listed the death as accidental. What is documented is the official finding of suicide; what surrounds it is the kind of contested afterlife that gathers around a man who lived at so many edges at once.

Afterlife and transmission

Randolph’s institutions were fragile and his finances ruinous, and at his death he might have seemed a marginal figure soon to be forgotten. The opposite happened. Within a decade his doctrines had crossed the Atlantic and lodged at the heart of the most consequential currents of the modern esoteric revival.

The decisive channel was the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor, the postal order that surfaced in Britain in the mid-1880s under Peter Davidson and Thomas Henry Burgoyne. The Brotherhood made the opposite wager to Theosophy: where Helena Blavatsky and the Theosophical Society located the wisdom in distant Himalayan masters and an Eastern literature, the H.B. of L. insisted the practical art belonged to the Western line and could be worked. The working it taught, transmitted through its handwritten correspondence course, was substantially Randolph’s: sexual polarity as the engine of the cosmos, and the sexual rite as the operative discipline. The order made sex central to its metaphysics in terms a reader of Eulis! recognizes at once — the union of male and female energies as the act that creates the world and the means of the soul’s reunion with the divine.

From the H.B. of L. the current ran further still. Its teachings reached the German occultists Carl Kellner and Theodor Reuss, who folded the doctrine of sexual magic into the upper degrees of the Ordo Templi Orientis at the turn of the century. The scholarship of Joscelyn Godwin and John Deveney has established the line plainly: the sexual magic of the higher O.T.O. degrees rests on a foundation laid by an African-American Spiritualist who never set foot in a German lodge. Through that order it passed to Crowley, and through Crowley into the broad stream of twentieth-century ritual magic — so that a great deal of what the modern West means by “sex magic” descends, at one or two removes, from the books of Paschal Beverly Randolph.

That descent went long unacknowledged. The orders that inherited his central teaching tended to bury the source, and the standard histories of Western esotericism for most of a century either omitted Randolph or treated him as a curiosity. Deveney’s biography reopened the case in 1997, and the recovery has accelerated since: Randolph now stands recognized as a pioneer of modern sexual magic, an early African-American novelist, a Reconstruction educator, and the founder of American Rosicrucianism — a single life that the categories of his century, and of ours, have struggled to hold together. The motto he carved on his emblem turns out to describe the reception as well as the man. Each succeeding generation has had to try again to read him whole.

→ Related: Rosicrucianism · Spiritualism · Occultism · Hermetic Brotherhood Of Luxor · Magic · Mesmerism Animal Magnetism · Esotericism · Theosophy · Theosophical Society · Helena Blavatsky · Golden Dawn Lineage · Ceremonial Magic · Alchemy · Aleister Crowley · Eliphas Levi Alphonse Louis Constant