Gotthold Ephraim Lessing

← Encyclopedia

Gotthold Ephraim Lessing was a German dramatist, critic, and philosopher of religion, born in Kamenz in Saxony in 1729 and dead at Brunswick in 1781 — one of the central writers of the German Enlightenment and, in the years after his death, the unwilling occasion of one of its sharpest quarrels. His standing rests first on the theatre and on criticism: plays that helped found a serious German drama, and essays that argued how art and faith should be judged. But the part of his work that reaches into the history of religious and esoteric thought lies at the end of his life, in two short texts and one reported conversation.

The first is The Education of the Human Race, published in full in 1780. In it Lessing treats revelation not as a fixed deposit handed down once and for all but as a tutor’s curriculum: God, he argues, gives humanity the truths it is ready to receive at each stage, so that revelation and reason are not rivals but earlier and later lessons in a single schooling. The argument folds the whole sequence of religions into a progress toward an autonomous morality — and, in its closing sections, entertains the possibility that the individual soul might return more than once to learn what it had missed. That speculative turn toward metempsychosis, offered tentatively rather than asserted, is what has drawn later esoteric and Theosophical readers to him, though Lessing himself frames it as a question, not a creed.

The second strand is the controversy that bears his name only because he was already dead when it broke. In 1785 Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi published an account of conversations held with Lessing shortly before his death, reporting that Lessing had declared himself a follower of Spinoza — that for him the orthodox conceptions of God were finished, and that he held to hen kai pan, the one-and-all. The claim was incendiary, because Spinozism was then a byword for atheism and fatalism. Moses Mendelssohn, Lessing’s friend, disputed Jacobi’s portrait; the exchange that followed, the Pantheism Controversy, drew in much of educated Germany and made Spinoza a live question rather than a forbidden name. A younger generation, Goethe among them, took from it a sympathetic reading of the one-and-all that fed directly into German idealism and Romanticism.

What scholarship can establish is the texts and the dates; what it cannot fully settle is the man’s own position, since the most famous statement of it survives only in an opponent’s memoir written after he could no longer answer. Lessing left the question deliberately open, and the openness was itself the point: he prized the search for truth, he wrote, above its secure possession. The controversy that followed turned that temperament into a doctrine he never quite signed.

→ Related: John Toland · Theodore Parker