Fatimid Neoplatonism

← Encyclopedia

Fatimid Neoplatonism is the philosophical cosmology worked out by thinkers of the Ismaili daʿwa — the missionary movement that supplied the Fatimid caliphate (909–1171) with its religious doctrine. It married the Neoplatonic account of how a many proceeds from a One to an Islamic frame in which scripture and prophet are themselves the staged unveiling of that order.

The reach for it was practical as much as speculative. The daʿwa taught a hidden sense beneath the revealed law, transmitted by an unbroken line of imams, and it needed a picture of reality grand enough to carry that claim. Neoplatonism supplied one. In the systems of Abū Yaʿqūb al-Sijistānī, writing in the tenth century, the visible cosmos descends by emanation from a first principle so far beyond being that it could be affirmed of neither existence nor non-existence — a God placed past the categories rather than at the top of them. From the divine command issued the Universal Intellect, complete and at rest; from the Intellect, the Universal Soul, which set the spheres turning and the lower world unfolding. The human soul, fallen into matter, climbs back the same ladder by knowledge.

What gave the doctrine its specific weight was taʾwīl — the drawing-out of an inner meaning. The teachers held that the literal text of revelation, like the visible world, was a surface; the prophets had spoken in figures, and the imam held the key. The grades of the missionary hierarchy were arranged to mirror the grades of the cosmos, so that to ascend through instruction was, on this reading, to retrace the soul’s descent in reverse.

The tradition was not fixed. Ḥamīd al-Dīn al-Kirmānī, active in the early eleventh century, judged the older two-principle scheme of Intellect and Soul inadequate and rebuilt the cosmology on the model of the philosophers’ ten separate intellects, the arrangement Islamic thinkers had taken from a Neoplatonized Aristotle. His revision did not displace the earlier system so much as run beside it, and later Ismaili writing drew on both.

Scholarship has established that these authors knew the Arabic Plotinus — the paraphrase circulating as the Theology of Aristotle — and reworked rather than merely repeated it, bending a pagan metaphysics of return toward a prophetology centred on the imam. How far the result is best read as philosophy clothing a sectarian politics, and how far as a genuine contemplative system, is a question the texts leave open; they argue in the idiom of the schools and close on the salvation of the soul. The resemblance to other emanationist currents — the Plotinian descent, the Kabbalistic sefirot, the gnostic fall and recovery of the spark — is real and has often been noticed. It is not identity. Each worked out its own grammar, and the Fatimid version kept the law it was reading into the bargain.

→ Related: Neoplatonism · Emanation · Nous · The One · Enochic Idris Prophetology