Bar and Bat Mitzvah

← Encyclopedia

Bar mitzvah and bat mitzvah mark the point at which a Jewish boy or girl becomes obligated to observe the commandments and is reckoned, in matters of religious law, an adult. The Hebrew and Aramaic phrases mean “son” and “daughter of the commandment” — mitzvah being both the individual precept and the body of obligation it stands for. A boy reaches this status at the age of thirteen, a girl traditionally at twelve. The crucial fact, easy to miss under the modern ceremony, is that the change happens by itself: the law holds that the young person becomes responsible on the relevant birthday whether or not anything is celebrated. The rite observed today recognises a transition already accomplished; it does not bring it about.

The age and the underlying principle are old. Rabbinic literature fixes thirteen as the threshold of obligation, and a saying in Pirkei Avot assigns that year to the commandments; from that point a person’s vows are binding and they may be counted toward a prayer quorum. The festive ceremony, however, is considerably later. Scholars trace the public marking — the young man called up to read from the Torah scroll before the congregation, often followed by a meal and a discourse — to medieval Ashkenaz, taking recognisable shape from roughly the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries onward. What had been a quiet legal coming-of-age acquired a communal liturgical form.

The bat mitzvah is more recent still. A formal ceremony for girls is largely a twentieth-century development, arising first in the modernising and liberal movements of American and European Judaism and spreading unevenly across the denominations. The forms it takes vary widely: in some communities the celebrant reads from the Torah exactly as a boy would; in others the occasion is marked without that public reading, in keeping with differing rulings on a woman’s role in the service. Orthodox, Conservative, Reform, and Reconstructionist practice diverge here in ways that reflect larger disagreements over law and gender, and the ceremony has become one of the visible places where those differences are read off.

For the tradition, the substance of the rite lies in obligation rather than festivity. To be bar or bat mitzvah is to be answerable — for one’s own keeping of the commandments, no longer covered by a parent’s responsibility. The reading from the Torah enacts that shift in the plainest possible terms: the young person takes a turn at the community’s central act, the public recitation of the scripture that the commandments come from. Around this core the surrounding celebration has grown, in some settings, very large; the elaboration is cultural, and the tradition has at times been uneasy about it. The legal kernel stays simple. A child becomes obligated, and the community notes that it is so.

→ Related: Circumcision · Torah · Talmud · Ten Commandments