Malachy

← Encyclopedia

Malachy of Armagh — Máel Máedóc Ua Morgair, 1094–1148 — was the leading churchman of twelfth-century Ireland: archbishop of Armagh, papal legate, and the figure who bound the Irish church more closely to the usages of Rome. His modern celebrity, however, comes from a document he had nothing to do with.

The historical man is well attested, and from an unusually authoritative source. Bernard of Clairvaux, who knew him, wrote his life shortly after his death and preserved much of what is known. Malachy rose through a church that had drifted from continental practice; he worked to regularise its dioceses, restore discipline, and align its observance with Roman norms, and he carried the cause to the papacy in person. On his second journey to Rome he stopped at Bernard’s abbey of Clairvaux, was taken with the Cistercian life, and arranged for the order to come to Ireland — the founding of Mellifont in 1142 followed from that visit. He died at Clairvaux in 1148, in Bernard’s arms, by the account; in 1190 he became the first Irishman to be formally canonised by a pope.

That is the documented life. Detached from it, and far better known, is the Prophecy of the Popes — a sequence of short Latin mottoes, one for each pope from the twelfth century to a last pontiff at the end of the age, the whole attributed to Malachy as a vision granted him in Rome. It first appeared in print in 1595, in a volume by the Benedictine Arnold de Wyon, and was promptly contested. The reasons are concrete: the mottoes describing popes up to the 1590s fit their subjects with suggestive ease, while those after that date grow vague and strained, exactly the pattern a forgery composed near its own publication would produce. Modern scholarship treats the text as a sixteenth- century pseudonymous composition, not a work of Malachy’s; nothing in Bernard’s life of him mentions any such prophecy.

The mottoes have nonetheless kept a long afterlife in popular eschatology, where each new papal election occasions fresh matching of the saint’s supposed phrases to the man elected. The list ends with a figure it calls Petrus Romanus, Peter the Roman, under whom the city is said to be destroyed and judgement to come — which has fixed the prophecy, in the reading of those who credit it, to the present generation. The interest in these last lines is genuine and recurrent; it has also outrun, by some centuries, the evidence that the lines were ever prophetic at all.

What survives of Malachy himself is the reformer and the friend of Bernard, a man whose actual labour reshaped a national church. The prophecy carries his name across the centuries the way a borrowed signature carries an author’s: the fame is real, the attribution is not.

→ Related: St Patrick · Divination