Puʻukoholā Heiau

← Encyclopedia

The answer came back from Kauaʻi in a person’s memory, the way answers traveled then, carried across the open channels to be spoken aloud on arrival. Kamehameha had sent to ask a kahuna named Kapoukahi what he must do to hold the island that kept slipping from his hands, and the word returned was precise. He was to build a great house for the god on the hill above Kawaihae, give it wholly to Kū-kā-ʻili-moku, and the god would deliver into his keeping not one island but all of them. It was a large thing to promise over a heap of unquarried stone. The hill was called Puʻukoholā, the hill of the whale, and what rose there over the next year would be a temple raised not to guard a district or bless a harvest but to conquer an ocean of islands — with the last chief who stood in the way named, in the same breath, as the price.

The place is a bluff on the leeward northwest coast of Hawaiʻi Island, above the small blue crescent of Pelekane Bay at Kawaihae, in the district of South Kohala. The name marks the ground itself: puʻu, a hill, and koholā, the humpback whale, which still winters in these warm lee waters and can be watched from the temple wall in season. A heiau is not a natural feature but a made one — a raised platform, a paepae, of drystone masonry laid up by hand — and Puʻukoholā is among the largest ever built in the islands. It does not stand alone. Just below it to the west lies the older Mailekini Heiau, and out beneath the surface of the bay, offshore of both, is Hale o Kapuni, a temple given to the sharks. The hill was already sacred ground before Kamehameha’s masons touched it: the National Park Service records an earlier temple on or near the spot dating to roughly 1580, so the war-temple of 1790–91 was raised upon consecrated earth, though whether the older structure stood on this exact footprint or beside it is not something the stones can now be made to say.

The hill of the whale, and a word before a stone

Within the tradition the story begins with a word rather than a stone. That order matters, because it is the prophet’s sentence, and not the masonry, that makes the temple what it is. Kapoukahi’s answer bound a specific hill to a specific god and made the whole archipelago the outcome of getting the building right. The completion had to be exact; the dedication had to be exact; a luakini half-built or wrongly consecrated would forfeit everything the god had offered. From the first, then, Puʻukoholā was a wager whose terms were spoken before a single course was laid.

How the account reaches the record is worth keeping distinct from the account itself. Two witnesses carry it. One is the ground — the platform survives, restored but unmistakable, and the archaeology preserved on the site is the hardest evidence there is of how such a temple was made. The other is the nineteenth-century Hawaiian historian Samuel Kamakau, whose narrative of Kamehameha’s rise is the principal written source for the building and its dedication, set down a lifetime later from the memories his own people had kept. Where a claim rests on the tradition — the prophecy, the sacrifice, the meaning of the god — its weight is Kamakau’s and that of the living recollection behind him; where it rests on a date or a measurement, on the documented and archaeological record. The two do not always overlap, and it is more honest to say which is speaking than to blur them into one voice.

The building of it is remembered as an act of the whole people, and of the chief among them. To raise the platform Kamehameha’s men are said to have formed a human chain reaching far up the coast to Pololū Valley in North Kohala, passing the water-worn stones hand to hand down the line to the hill — accounts give the distance variously, from about fourteen miles to twenty or more, and the number matters less than the image it preserves: a living conveyor of people, miles long, moving a mountain of stone by touch. Kamehameha’s brother Keliʻimaikaʻi is remembered as overseeing the labor, and the chief himself is remembered as working in the line, a ruling aliʻi carrying stone with his own hands because the god’s house could not be raised by anyone else’s virtue. The platform went up without mortar, each stone fitted dry against the next, and by the summer of 1791 it was complete.

Puʻukoholā Heiau — “the hill of the whale” — the great luakini raised by Kamehameha in 1790–91 above Pelekane Bay at Kawaihae, its terraced drystone platform some 224 feet long. Ken Lund, via Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 2.0.

The temple built to conquer an archipelago

A luakini was the highest and most sacred class of Hawaiian temple, the war-temple where the ruling chief — the aliʻi nui — sought the mana and the sanction of Kū for kingship and for conquest. It was the sternest institution of the old order, and its rites, when the god demanded, could culminate in the offering of a human life; that offering belonged to Kū and to the ruling line alone, was bound to the authority of the chief and the sanctioning of a campaign, and is described here at the distance of the public record, never as spectacle and never with the closed detail of the rite. The fuller shape of the war-god’s cult — its severity, its images, its place in the Hawaiian year against the peace of the Makahiki — belongs to the account of the god himself, at Kū. What belongs to the hill is what the god was here asked to do.

Kū-kā-ʻili-moku means, in the tradition’s own gloss, Kū the snatcher of the land — the seizer of islands. He was Kamehameha’s inherited guardian akua, a feathered image handed down the chiefly succession of Hawaiʻi Island, which had passed to Kamehameha from his uncle the high chief Kalaniʻōpuʻu and was carried, tradition says, into the front of his battles. The image is the god’s dwelling and his sensible presence in the world — never an “idol,” a word that belongs to a hostile outside vocabulary and is set aside here. To build Puʻukoholā was therefore not simply to construct a platform. It was to enter a covenant: the temple, rightly made and rightly given, would house the island-snatching god and bind him to the chief who housed him, and the prophet’s word had already staked the whole chain of islands on the bargain.

The scale of the thing is itself an argument. The finished platform runs roughly 224 feet in length by 100 feet in width, its drystone walls standing between sixteen and twenty feet high — a structure the length of a ship and the height of a house, raised in under a year. Nothing about it is modest, because nothing about the wager was modest. A temple this size, on this hill, dedicated to this god, is a claim made in stone before the god was even asked to honor it: a house built to the measure of an ambition to rule every island in the sea.

Within the frame of the sacred world the temple’s power was real and, crucially, answerable. This was not a gesture of piety in the hope of a vague favor. The god who was properly housed and properly served would deliver what had been promised — dominion — and the failure to complete or consecrate him correctly would as surely forfeit it. The bargain ran both ways, which is why the exactness mattered so much, and why the dedication, when it came, could admit no flaw.

The hill is the center of a whole working landscape of the akua, the ancestors, and the chiefs, and the sharks are part of it. The submerged Hale o Kapuni offshore was given to the manō, some of them ʻaumakua — ancestral guardian spirits — of the Kohala chiefs, and above the shore a leaning pōhaku, a stone post, is remembered as the place from which a high chief could watch the sharks gather to the offerings set out for them. Mailekini below, older than Puʻukoholā, was a temple in its own right before the war-temple ever rose over it. To read this as three separate sites is to miss that it is one system: the god on the hill, the sharks in the bay, the ancestors in both, and the aliʻi moving among them as the human hinge on which the whole arrangement turned.

Where the luakini order itself came from is genuinely contested, and the contest is worth marking. Hawaiian tradition credits the strict form of the war-temple, and the coming of human sacrifice into Kū’s worship, to a priest named Paʻao, said to have voyaged from Kahiki — the ancestral homeland whose name is cognate with Tahiti — and to have stiffened the kapu and raised the chiefs’ rank in an earlier age. That story implies a second migration and a Tahitian imposition on an older stratum, a model modern archaeology has largely abandoned for want of evidence, even as many Kanaka Maoli hold Paʻao a historical man. The disputed second voyage and the origins of the cult belong to the Tahitians; what belongs to Puʻukoholā is that the institution Kamehameha invoked here was old, severe, and understood by all parties to be capable of doing exactly what the prophet said it would.

The dedication, and the price the god named

The temple was finished in the summer of 1791, and its consecration is among the most weighed moments in Hawaiian history. Kamehameha’s last great rival on the island was his cousin Keōua Kūʻahuʻula, chief of the district of Kaʻū to the south and, like Kamehameha, a son of the line of Kalaniʻōpuʻu; he still held the eastern districts and had fought Kamehameha to no decision through years of raids. Fortune had already turned against him in a way the tradition read plainly. In 1790, as Keōua’s army crossed the summit desert of Kīlauea, the volcano erupted in the ash-blast the Hawaiians called Keonehelelei, the falling sands, and killed a part of his force where they walked — a stroke understood, from within, as the hand of Pele at the center of events. The god of the hill and the goddess of the crater seemed to be moving together, and against Keōua.

Summoned to Kawaihae — by some accounts under the guise of a negotiated peace — Keōua came by canoe to Pelekane. Kamakau’s account preserves a detail that has been read in more than one way ever since: that Keōua, bathing before he landed, performed a ritual act of self-mutilation. To Kamakau it marks a man who knew he was going to his death and prepared himself for it; other readings take it as an attempt to render himself a blemished, imperfect offering, an unfit victim who would spoil the sacrifice he saw coming. The exact meaning, like the exact circumstances of what followed, is not fully settled, and it is fairer to hold the readings side by side than to choose between them with a confidence the sources do not license. What is not in dispute is the outcome. As Keōua stepped ashore he was struck down — a spear first, then musket fire — and the guns were no accident of the scene. By 1791 Kamehameha’s war-machine included the shipwrecked British sailors John Young and Isaac Davis and the cannon of the schooner Fair American, taken the year before; the foreign gunnery that helped decide his campaigns was present at the water’s edge. Keōua’s body was carried up the hill and offered at the newly finished temple, and with that offering the luakini was consecrated to Kū.

The dry-laid platform of Puʻukoholā, restored and preserved on its hill above Kawaihae — the last major temple raised in the old Hawaiian order, and the ground on which Kamehameha’s bid for the archipelago was consecrated. Bamse, via Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 3.0.

With Keōua dead, Kamehameha held Hawaiʻi Island entire, and the prophecy began to move toward its fulfillment. The island became the base from which, over the next two decades, he brought the rest of the chain under a single rule; by 1810 the archipelago was one kingdom, and the wager Kapoukahi had named over an unbuilt hill had been paid out in full. That larger unification, and the century that followed it, is told where it belongs, with the Kanaka Maoli themselves; the hill’s own share of it is that the whole thing began here, with one cousin’s body and one god’s promise kept.

The temple did not remain in use. When the old religion’s central institution was set aside — in the ʻai noa of 1819, when the ruling chiefs themselves broke the eating kapu and the temple images were taken down across the kingdom — the luakini of Puʻukoholā fell silent with the rest, a year before the first Calvinist missionaries arrived in 1820 to see such places only through the distorting lens of “idolatry.” That frame is named here in order to refuse it: what stood on the hill was the central rite of a great Polynesian religion, and the missionary word for it records the observer’s contempt and not the thing observed. The temple that a full stone wall could turn from a place of death into a place of absolution stands elsewhere on this coast, at Puʻuhonua o Hōnaunau; Puʻukoholā was the other pole of the same sacred order, the place where the seizing of an archipelago was ratified before the god who was that seizing.

The ground below the temple kept being used, though for other ends. John Young, the British advisor whose guns had been at Pelekane, settled nearby, built a house and ranch on the flat, and converted the older Mailekini Heiau into a fort to guard the harbor — an old temple turned to cannon, a small emblem of the whole altered century.

The site passed into the modern frame of protection in stages. Puʻukoholā was designated a National Historic Landmark on December 29, 1962, and added to the National Register of Historic Places on October 15, 1966. On August 17, 1972, an Act of Congress established Puʻukoholā Heiau National Historic Site, some eighty-six acres on the hill and shore now administered by the National Park Service, which preserves the platform, the ruin of Mailekini, the submerged Hale o Kapuni, and the leaning stone above the water as a single complex.

It is, above all, a living place of the Kanaka Maoli, and its present life turns on the same word that raised it. Each year around the anniversary of the site’s establishment the National Park Service and Native Hawaiian practitioners hold the Hoʻokuʻikahi Establishment Day Hawaiian Cultural Festival on the hill — hoʻokuʻikahi meaning to unify, to make into one. The name is deliberate. At the bicentennial of the temple’s consecration in 1991, the descendants of Kamehameha and of Keōua were brought together at Puʻukoholā to reconcile the two lines that the dedication had set against each other, and the festival that gathers there now — with its protocol, its chant, its hula, and its makahiki games — carries that reconciliation forward and renews the traditions the temple embodies.

The wager the priest named has long since been paid out: one island, then an archipelago, then a kingdom that a century later would itself be taken from the Kanaka Maoli by other hands. What still stands on the hill is the stone that was the stake — a platform the length of a ship, raised in a single year by a people passing water-smoothed rocks miles down a human chain, to house a god who had promised them the sea. And each summer the ones who carry both bloodlines climb to it together, so that the offering laid at Puʻukoholā now is the peace between them.

→ Related: Pele · Kane · Ku Hawaiian · Lono · Kanaloa · Kilauea · Haleakala · Puuhonua O Honaunau · The Marquesans · The Tahitians · The Kanaka Maoli