Pluto

← Encyclopedia

Pluto is the Greco-Roman god of the dead and of the world beneath the earth — in Greek Ploutōn, in Latin Pluto or Dis. The name is itself a softening. The older Greek word for the lord of the dead was Hades, which also named his realm, and the Greeks were reluctant to say it: a god whom no prayer moved and no sacrifice turned aside was better addressed by a kinder title. Ploutōn, from ploutos, “wealth,” does that work. The earth that swallows the dead is also the earth from which grain rises and ore is dug, and the god who holds the one was held to dispense the other.

The euphemism is not a poet’s flourish but a theology compressed into a name. Greek riches came from below: the seed buried in the autumn furrow, the metal prized out of the mountain, the spring that surfaces from a hidden source. The philologists trace ploutos to a root meaning to flow or to overflow — wealth as abundance welling up — and the image fits the god exactly, for what wells up does so from underground, out of his keeping. All of it belongs to the dominion that also receives the dead, so that the same power presides over loss and over increase, over the body laid in the ground and the harvest drawn up from it. The horn of plenty that later art puts in his hand is the same object Persephone’s son Ploutos carries, the overflowing cornucopia: the god of the grave holds the emblem of the granary, and the two are not in tension but in sequence. To call the dread lord the wealthy one is to name the second face of the first: the chthonic god is an agrarian god, and the gesture that hides the grim title is also a recognition that descent and fertility are a single circuit. The Latin equivalent makes the logic explicit. Dis Pater, the form the Romans matched to Plouton, means the rich father — by the likeliest reading a direct calque of the Greek, the wealth held under the ground transposed into a god’s title without disguise. Pluto and the planet that took his name in 1930 share a word and almost nothing else; what the name carries is older than any sky.

The abduction and the bargain of the seasons

In the myths he is most often the abductor. The best-known story, told in the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, has him seize Persephone, daughter of Demeter, and carry her below to be queen of the dead. The seizure is not lawless: in the Hymn it is undertaken with the consent of Zeus, her father, who grants the girl to his brother — so that the violence done to mother and daughter is also a transaction among the male powers who divide the cosmos between them. Demeter’s grief is the engine of the story. Withdrawing from the company of the gods, the grain-goddess lets the fields go barren; nothing sprouts, the plow turns dead furrows, and the race of mortals stands to starve, which is to say the gods stand to lose their sacrifices. The deadlock breaks only by a settlement. Persephone is returned — but because she has eaten of the pomegranate in the underworld, a seed-fruit that binds whoever tastes it to the place, she must spend a portion of each year below and the rest above. Her descent is the fallow season; her return is the greening of the world. The myth that explains why grain dies and rises is the same myth that installs the lord of the dead as a husband and a king, and it is told to account for the seasons themselves.

The settlement also fixes Persephone in two registers that the cult never fully merged: Kore the maiden gathered from the meadow, and the dread queen who shares the dark throne. Pluto’s character is read off hers. As her abductor he is the unappeasable power of seizure; as her consort, enthroned beside her over the assembled dead, he is a settled sovereign, grave rather than cruel, the one who keeps what is owed and releases what is granted. The marriage that began in rape becomes, in the iconography and the inscriptions, a reign.

A god with few altars

Greek cult kept its distance from him otherwise. Temples to Hades were few, and he received little of the ordinary devotion paid to the Olympians — no great civic festival, no crowded sanctuary, no oracle to consult. The reason is not neglect but dread: a god whose decree no offering reverses is approached sidelong, with averted face and a turned-away libation, not courted in the open manner of Zeus or Apollo. Where his worship surfaces, it surfaces underground in the literal sense — at chthonic clefts and caves reputed to open onto his realm. Such a precinct was the Ploutonion, the shrine of Plouton; the best documented stood at the north edge of the sanctuary at Eleusis, a cave-shrine built under the tyrant Peisistratos in the sixth century BCE and rebuilt when the Mysteries were at their height. The cave was held to be the very mouth by which the abducted Persephone went down and came back, and also the birthplace of the divine child Ploutos — wealth itself born from the underworld threshold. Other sites carried the same charge: the gas-breathing fissures at Hierapolis and Acharaca in Asia Minor, the headland at Tainaron in the Peloponnese, Lake Avernus in Italy, each a place where the membrane between the worlds was thought to be thin.

The Romans identified their own Dis Pater with him and used Pluto and Dis more or less interchangeably; with Jupiter and Neptune as the brothers who drew sky and sea, Dis held the third lot, the realm below, inheriting in the Latin frame the place that Greek myth gave to Hades. Alongside Dis the Latin imagination kept a second name, Orcus, which leaned toward the punishing aspect — the power that seizes and torments, the devourer of the dead — and which stood at times for the ruler and at times for the realm. Where Dis Pater carried the dignity of the rich father, Orcus carried the menace; the two names parcel out between them the doubleness already folded into Plouton. The underworld as a place the Latin poets could also call by the ruler’s name, so that to go down to Orcus and to go to the god were one phrase.

The grim god and the gentle Plouton

The Eleusinian Mysteries complicate the picture. There, alongside the dread god, a figure named Plouton appears in a gentler aspect, bound to the agrarian hope the rites promised — the same name, but turned toward increase and return rather than seizure. In the Mysteries he and Persephone are the divine pair who receive the initiate, invoked together on the dedications, no longer captor and captive but enthroned hosts of the blessed dead. The name Ploutōn enters surviving Greek literature in just this register, in Athenian drama close to the Eleusinian world — in Aristophanes’ Frogs of 405 BCE the lord of the dead appears as a character under that name, in a play steeped in the imagery of the Mysteries. The euphemism and the cult that softened the god move together.

How sharply the ancients themselves separated the grim Hades from this kindlier Plouton is a question scholarship leaves open; the sources allow both a single ambivalent deity and a deliberate doubling. Lewis Farnell, surveying the Greek cults at the turn of the twentieth century, treated Hades-Plouton as one god held under a double name, the second title growing up to express the benign side that the first suppressed. Others read the evidence as a real bifurcation — the unworshipped Hades of the abduction on one side, the cultivated Plouton of the threshold-shrines on the other — closer to two figures than to one. The ambivalence is not an error to be resolved but the structure of the thing: a god who is dread and gift at once requires a name for each face, and the cult that needed his good will more than his terror naturally amplified the wealthy name.

The cult that needed his favor also gave him other names. At Eleusis he was called Eubouleus, “the good counselor,” a euphemism atop a euphemism, the dark king reimagined as a giver of sound advice; the swineherd Eubouleus whose pigs fell into the chasm at the moment of the abduction belongs to the same nexus of the threshold and the buried. The benign titles cluster where the cult is warmest — at the agrarian shrines, in the Mysteries — while the cold name Hades holds the open myth. The pattern is consistent: the more a community had to ask of the god of the dead, the kinder the name by which it asked.

Beyond the public rites, the underworld and its queen pass into the eschatology of the mystery cults and of the Orphic poems. The thin gold leaves buried with initiates across Magna Graecia, Thessaly, and Crete — the so-called Bacchic-Orphic tablets — give the dead soul its instructions for the journey below and address Persephone as the power who, with Dionysus as the agent of release, may grant the blessed lot. In that literature the realm Pluto rules is no longer only a place of grim retention but a court at which a destiny is decided. The same Persephone stands at a hinge of the Orphic theogonies, where she is engendered by Zeus and bears Dionysus, the son the Titans dismember — so that the queen of Pluto’s realm becomes, in that poetry, the mother of the god through whom the soul is released from the very world below that she governs. The singer Orpheus, whose descent to recover Eurydice is Greek myth’s central image of art set against death, came before that throne and very nearly carried his bargain out of it — the one mortal whose song moved the unmovable god, and who lost the prize at the threshold by looking back.

The textual and scholarly record

The primary witness to Pluto’s central myth is the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, a hexameter narrative of perhaps the seventh or sixth century BCE that recounts the abduction, Demeter’s wandering grief, the founding of the rites at Eleusis, and the seasonal settlement. The Greek text with the standard public-domain English of Hugh G. Evelyn-White (Loeb, 1914) is freely available through the Perseus Digital Library; Andrew Lang’s elegant prose version (1899) and the facing-page Evelyn-White Loeb are the priority public-domain editions. For the iconography and cult of Pluto and Persephone as the Eleusinian pair, the site report on the Plutonion at Eleusis reconstructs the cave-shrine and its place at the north entrance of the sanctuary. The standard nineteenth-century survey of the god’s worship remains Lewis Richard Farnell’s The Cults of the Greek States (Oxford, 1896–1909), of which the chapter “Cults of Hades-Plouton” in volume III treats Demeter, Kore-Persephone, and Hades-Plouton together as a single cult-complex; the volume is long out of copyright. For the underworld eschatology that gathers around Pluto’s queen, Fritz Graf and Sarah Iles Johnston’s Ritual Texts for the Afterlife (Routledge, 2007) is the standard edition of the gold tablets, and Walter Burkert’s Greek Religion (English translation, Harvard, 1985) the standard account of the chthonic cults and their reticence. Roman Dis Pater and Orcus are handled in the older reference literature — William Smith’s Dictionary of Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology (1849) gives the entries on Pluton, Dis, and Orcus — and in the standard modern handbooks of Roman religion.

The longest afterlife of the word is astronomical and astrological, but it is afterlife and not the god. When a ninth planet was found at the edge of the solar system in 1930, it was named Pluto — fittingly for a body in the cold and dark at the system’s rim — and the older god supplied the word without supplying much else. Astrology then took the new planet up and assigned it meanings drawn loosely from the god’s associations: depths, the buried, death and what survives it, transformation through descent. That reading is a modern construction, built after 1930 and lacking any ancient warrant, however much it borrows the god’s atmosphere. The planet entered an art of the heavens that had named its other planets after the same Olympians long before — the Greek and then Hellenistic astrologers inheriting from Babylonia the practice of fixing the gods to the wandering lights, so that Jupiter and Saturn carried their rulers’ powers across the sky. Pluto arrived into that grammar two millennia late, and the planet’s later demotion among astronomers left the astrological Pluto untouched, since the two had never depended on each other.

The god beneath the borrowed word keeps his own logic. He is the term toward which everything tends and from which the season’s increase is drawn back up — the unmoved sovereign whose name says wealth precisely because the ground that takes the dead is the ground that yields the grain. To the Greek who turned his face and poured the libation downward, Plouton was not a thief of life but its banker, holding what is owed against the day it is returned: the seed in winter, the daughter for her months, the initiate’s portion among the blessed. The realm he rules has no exit for most who enter it, and yet the whole shape of his worship turns on what comes back — Kore in spring, the harvest from the furrow, the soul that knew the right spring to drink from. He is the keeper of the lower account — and what he keeps, in the wealthier reading, he keeps only against the day it is drawn back up.

→ Related: Orpheus · Vulcan · Themis · Persephone · Demeter · Eleusis · Dionysus · Zeus · Jupiter · Saturn · Hermes · Mystery Religions · Astrology