Pierre Nicole

← Encyclopedia

Pierre Nicole (1625–1695) was a French moral theologian and logician attached to Port-Royal, the convent and intellectual circle that became the heart of the Jansenist movement in seventeenth-century France. He is remembered on two counts: as the close collaborator of Antoine Arnauld, with whom he wrote the work known as the Port-Royal Logic, and as the author of the Essais de morale, a long sequence of essays on conduct and the inner life that made him one of the most widely read religious writers of the French classical age.

Jansenism, the current to which Nicole belonged, was a rigorist movement within Catholicism that took its name from the Flemish bishop Cornelius Jansen and pressed an austere, Augustinian reading of grace and human helplessness. Its adherents held that fallen human nature could do nothing toward its own salvation without an efficacious grace given by God alone — a position the papacy condemned and the Jesuits opposed, and which drew Port-Royal into decades of controversy and eventual suppression. Nicole spent much of his life inside that struggle, writing in its defense, and at points fleeing into exile when the crown moved against the movement.

His lasting influence runs along two lines. The first is logical. La Logique, ou l’art de penser (1662), composed with Arnauld, was the most successful philosophy textbook of its era, reprinted across Europe for two centuries; it recast logic as an account of how the mind actually reasons, and its treatment of signs and ideas left a mark on later philosophy of language that scholars still trace. The second is moral and devotional. The Essais de morale analyzed self-love, vanity, civility, and the disguises by which pride imitates virtue, with a cool psychological precision that drew admirers well beyond Jansenist circles. The young correspondents of the age read him; later moralists borrowed from him; and his pages on the social uses of self-interest have been read as an early intimation of arguments that economics would later make its own.

Nicole’s relation to his own party was not always easy. More cautious than the combative Arnauld, he counseled accommodation where others wanted to fight, and in his later years he distanced himself somewhat from the harder Jansenist line, which won him the distrust of stricter colleagues. What he held throughout was a conviction that the examination of the human heart — its evasions, its hidden appetites, its capacity for self-deception — was itself a religious task. He wrote as a man persuaded that grace was everything and that the mind, left to itself, was mostly engaged in flattering itself; the Essais are the patient working-out of that double thought. He died in Paris in 1695, the controversies he had served still unresolved, his books already passing into the common reading of educated Europe.

→ Related: Jean Astruc · Martin Chemnitz