Oenone

← Encyclopedia

Oenone is a nymph of Mount Ida in the Troad, known in Greek myth as the first wife of Paris and as the woman who could have healed his death-wound and would not. The sources make her a daughter of the river-god Cebren — Ovid’s verse-letter calls her a fountain-nymph sprung from a great river, and gives Xanthus as the alternate father — and place her among the local powers of the mountain: neither a goddess of the great pantheon nor quite mortal, but one of the lesser divinities bound to a particular spring and slope. She belongs to the company of the naiads and freshwater spirits, a daughter of running water on a wooded height above the plain where, later, the war would be fought.

The herdsman and the two gifts

Paris was reared as a herdsman on Ida before his royal birth and Trojan ancestry came to be known, and there, on the slopes, he loved Oenone and married her. Parthenius preserves the pastoral scene — the shepherd and the nymph among the pines, a son born to them named Corythus — and records that Paris swore he would never desert her. The oath is the hinge on which the whole story turns, because Oenone had two gifts, and one of them showed her how the oath would break.

The first gift was medicine. Apollo, the poets say, had taught her the herbs that close wounds, the roots and simples that draw out poison and knit torn flesh. This is the rarest thing in her myth and the thing that holds it together: she is not only a seer but a healer, an art she shares with the god of healing himself and, through him, with the line of Asclepius. Where the river-nymphs of Greek story are usually loved and lost and left to grieve, Oenone is given a power over the body’s wound — which means the story can do something other stories cannot. It can let her hold the cure and refuse to open her hand.

The second gift was prophecy. The fullest source for it, the mythographer Apollodorus, says she had learned the art of foretelling from Rhea, the mother of the gods — though the popular tradition folds both gifts under Apollo, the god of the oracle as well as the herb. By that sight she foresaw the shape of Paris’s ruin: that he would cross the sea, take a foreign wife, and bring war home with him. She warned him not to sail. Failing to turn him, she told him — and this detail, from Apollodorus, is the seed of the ending — that if he were ever wounded he should come to her, for she alone could heal him. He left her for Helen of Sparta, and every word she had spoken came true.

Corythus

A darker middle stands between the warning and the wound, and the mythographers do not all tell it the same way. The son, Corythus, grew to a beauty like his father’s and came to Troy — in Parthenius and in Conon’s prose summary of the local legend — where Helen received him warmly, and Paris, not knowing the youth for his own son, killed him out of jealousy. Some tellings make Oenone the hand behind it, sending Corythus to sow discord between Paris and Helen, or to guide the Greeks to Troy, so that the abandoned wife works her injury through the child. The strand sharpens the grievance she will later carry up the mountain: by the time Paris is brought back to her, she has not only been left for Helen but has, in some versions, lost a son to him.

The last act

The end belongs to the last summer of the Trojan War. Paris was struck by one of the poisoned arrows of Philoctetes — the shafts envenomed with the blood of the Hydra, carried in the bow that had been Heracles’, against which no ordinary medicine holds. Quintus Smyrnaeus, who tells the death at length, has the venom crawling through him as he is carried back up Ida to the only person living who could undo it. He comes to her feet and asks for the cure she once promised.

Accounts differ on what happens next, and the difference is the heart of the figure. In the fullest versions she refuses, still wounded by the abandonment and, where Corythus is part of the tale, by worse; Paris turns back toward Troy and dies on the mountain before he reaches it. Stricken then by grief or remorse, Oenone goes after him. Apollodorus has her relent and gather the healing drugs, only to find him already dead, and hang herself; Quintus has her cast herself onto his burning pyre, so that the two are burned together and buried side by side, their grave-markers set facing apart. A third strand, in Lycophron’s riddling Alexandra, throws her from the walls of Troy. The relenting-too-late variant — the cure brought a moment after it can be used — is the softening the later tradition reached for, but no version lets her live. What every telling keeps is the terrible symmetry: the healer who withholds the cure, and cannot outlive the withholding.

Source-history

The story is not Homeric. The Iliad and Odyssey, which know Paris and Helen intimately, are silent on the first wife; Oenone enters the record from the side, in the local lore of the Troad rather than the central epic. The earliest sure traces are Hellenistic and later — a name in Lycophron’s dense allusive catalog of Troy’s aftermath, the developed romance in Parthenius’s Erotica Pathemata (the “Sorrows of Love”), the prose summary preserved in Conon’s Narrations, known to us through the epitome made by the Byzantine patriarch Photius, the full mythographic account in Apollodorus, and the long death-scene in Quintus Smyrnaeus’s Posthomerica, the late epic that fills the gap between the Iliad and the fall of the city. Across these the details migrate: the father is Cebren or Xanthus, the teacher of prophecy is Rhea or Apollo, the death is a hanging or a leap onto the pyre or a fall from the walls. The figure is the kind of regional tale that accretes around a great epic and a named landscape — a story fastened to a particular spring, a particular slope, a particular grave on Ida — rather than a fragment broken off the central poem.

Ovid gives her something the mythographers do not: a voice. In the fifth of the Heroides, the collection of verse-letters from the heroines of legend (the Latin text and an early English rendering are at Perseus), Oenone writes to Paris as the wife he has left, before the war’s end and before she knows how the story closes. She recalls the names they cut together into the bark of the trees, names that grew as the trees grew; she sets her own constancy against his betrayal; and she turns her healer’s art into the cruelest line in her record — that every herb potent to heal grows somewhere in the world and is hers to gather, and that of all wounds the one she carries is the single one no herb can close. Love is the wound her medicine cannot reach. The irony Ovid found in her is the irony the whole myth is built on, stated from the inside.

The reading of the figure

Timothy Gantz, whose survey of the literary and artistic sources is the standard map of where each version stands, places Oenone among the post-Homeric accretions to the Trojan cycle, a local Trojan legend rather than an old epic strand. Read so, she sits among the nymphs of place — the female powers tied to water and mountain who appear across Greek myth in love with mortal men and undone by the meeting, Echo and Calypso and Daphne among them, each bound to a spring or a tree or an island and each defined by a love that does not hold. Her prophetic sight aligns her with the seers whose knowledge cannot avert what they foresee — with Cassandra, the Trojan princess whose true prophecies no one heeds; with Calchas, the Greek diviner of the same war; with blind Tiresias; the whole company for whom prophecy is a clear view of a thing they are powerless to stop. And the pattern of her grief — the spring-nymph who could not save the one she loved — runs close to Juturna, the fountain-goddess kept deathless while her brother dies, and to Glaucus, the sea-creature gifted with foresight and the bitter knowledge of what it cannot prevent.

What is distinct to Oenone is the medicine. The other nymphs of place lose what they love to fate, or to a god’s jealousy, or to the simple fact of a mortal’s death; the loss happens to them. Oenone alone holds the remedy in her own two hands. The power to heal is rarely given to the one who is wronged, and rarer still is the story willing to let her keep it shut — to make the refusal an act, not an accident, and to set against it the cure brought too late, the drugs gathered for a man already cold. The myth does not moralize the refusal. It records it, and lets the two deaths stand.

→ Related: Juturna · Acis · Glaucus · Philoctetes · Apollo · Helen Of Troy · Cassandra · Calchas · Tiresias · Prophecy · Asclepius · Daphne · Echo · Calypso · Hellenistic Period