Ludwig Feuerbach

← Encyclopedia

Ludwig Feuerbach (1804–1872) was a German philosopher best known for the claim that religion is a projection: that in worshipping God, human beings worship the idealized image of their own nature, returned to them as something foreign and above them. His The Essence of Christianity (1841) made the argument that gave him his lasting place — theology, he held, is anthropology that has forgotten what it is about.

He came up through the German philosophy of his day, studying briefly under Hegel in Berlin and beginning as one of the Young Hegelians, the younger generation that turned Hegel’s system to critical and political ends. Hegel had described history as the unfolding of an Absolute Spirit coming to know itself. Feuerbach inverted the picture. The truth of religion, he argued, was not a hidden divine subject but the human subject all along: the perfections ascribed to God — infinite love, infinite knowledge, infinite will — are the powers of the human species, abstracted from any individual, magnified without limit, and then set over against the worshipper as a separate being. The human being, in this account, is impoverished exactly to the degree that the imagined God is enriched. This, he held, was the mystery of religion: the human being projects its own essence outward into something objective, and then bows to that projection as though it were a separate power standing over it.

The aim, as Feuerbach stated it, was not to abolish religion but to decode it — to recover for humanity the goods it had displaced into heaven. He read the Christian doctrines this way one by one: the Trinity as the human need for relationship, providence as the species’ love of itself, the incarnation as a recognition that the divine and the human were never two things. What looked like a demolition was offered, in his own framing, as a translation.

His influence ran through the radical thought that followed him. Marx and Engels absorbed the projection argument and then turned it against Feuerbach himself, charging that he had explained religion without explaining the social conditions that produced the need for it; Engels later recalled that the book’s appearance had made him and his circle “at once Feuerbachians.” In English his reach owed much to a single translation: the 1854 rendering of The Essence of Christianity by Marian Evans, better known as the novelist George Eliot, which carried his thesis into Victorian debate over faith and doubt.

Feuerbach belongs to the critical tradition that treats religion as a human fact to be understood rather than a revelation to be received, and his projection thesis became one of the standard tools of that tradition, taken up and reworked long after the particulars of his Hegelian setting had faded. Whether the account explains religion or only redescribes it has been argued ever since. The question he pressed — what, in the divine, is the human looking at — outlived the system it came from.

→ Related: Apotheosis · Absolute