Lebe

← Encyclopedia

The grave was opened for the bones. In the account the Dogon keep of their own beginnings, the people had carried the memory of a dead ancestor west to east across the Sahel, out of the Mandé country and toward the long sandstone wall that would become their home, and when the time came to gather what remained of him for the road they dug down and found no bones at all. A great living serpent lay coiled in the pit. It did not strike. It moved off toward the cliffs, and the people went after it, and the ground it brought them to is the ground they still farm. The ancestor whose grave that was is Lebe — Lebe Serou, sometimes written Lébé Seru — and the serpent was not a sign of him but the shape he had become. He is the one who died and then was the earth.

Genealogy: the ancestor who died

His name carries the death in it. Lebe Serou — Lébé Seru in another common transcription — is sometimes read as “witness of Lebe,” and the ancestor is a witness in the plainest sense: the first to undergo the thing all the living would afterward undergo, and the first to be brought back from it changed. The tradition places his story at the far end of a migration the Dogon still recount, a movement out of the Mandé heartland to the west and eastward to the cliff, conventionally set around the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, into a country where an older cliff-dwelling people, the Tellem, had built their granaries and buried their dead in the high rock some centuries before. The grave that was opened belongs to that crossing. It is the hinge on which a wandering people became a settled one, and the sign that turned them was the ancestor himself, remade as the thing that lives in the ground.

Lebe reaches the record along two roads that do not perfectly agree, and an honest account has to keep both in view. The first is the living cult itself: the Dogon of the Bandiagara escarpment maintain, in every village, an altar to Lebe worked through with sacred earth, and a priesthood attached to it, and this devotion is present and observed rather than reconstructed. The second is the great ethnographic synthesis assembled by the French school of Marcel Griaule from the 1930s onward — the conversations Griaule held with the blind elder Ogotemmêli, published in 1948 as Dieu d’eau, and the vast posthumous Le Renard pâle (1965) completed by his collaborator Germaine Dieterlen. Nearly every intricate turn of the Lebe story as the wider world knows it — the exact sequence of the first death, the swallowing by the water-spirit, the bones laid out as colored stones — comes through that synthesis, and its depth is disputed. It is best read as a rich reconstruction built with a few gifted elders, not as a doctrine one could gather from any Dogon at any altar.

In the cosmogony the Griaule school recorded, Lebe stands among the primordial ancestors, the offspring of the creator Amma and the ordering water-twins, the Nommo. The ancestors were not meant to die. They were to pass into the earth by transforming — shedding the human form and slipping into the ground as serpents in the manner of the Nommo, who are amphibious below and human above — and so to cross into the other state without the rupture of death. The order broke in the passage. One telling has Lebe’s own younger son turn prematurely into a snake, tripping the sequence and loosing the taboo of dying; another simply holds that Lebe alone failed to complete the change. Either way the result is the same: he died in the form of a man, and being a man’s corpse he was buried. Lebe is, in the Dogon phrase, the ancestor of death — not death’s author so much as its first subject, the one on whom mortality was first spent.

The deepest and most contested episode belongs to Ogotemmêli’s telling. Into the grave came the seventh Nommo, half serpent below and half man above, the same sacrificed and regenerated being who is the pivot of the whole cosmogony. He swallowed Lebe’s body so that it could be made over, then vomited a torrent of water across it, and laid the bones out again as a pattern of colored stones — stones that in the tradition became sacred objects worn by the priests. What the grave held, when the Dogon opened it during the migration, was therefore not the failure of the ancestor but his completion: the man who could not become a serpent had been made into one after all, by the water-power, and the earth-snake that led the people to the cliff was Lebe finished. This is the layer that most needs its source marked. It is Ogotemmêli’s account to Griaule, and the elaborate architecture around it — the swallowing, the vomited water, the bones read as a sequence of colored stones — is exactly what a later fieldworker could not find in ordinary hands. The name and the devotion belong to the Dogon and are not in doubt; the deep interior of the myth belongs to a particular elder and a particular ethnographer, and is reported through Griaule’s record rather than gathered from the village at large.

Teaching: the earth made person

Within the Dogon world Lebe holds one of the three great offices of being. Amma is the sky and the first cause, remote at the source of things; the Nommo are the water, the ordered moisture and the word; Lebe is the earth — the cultivated ground itself, made person and then folded back into the person’s own soil. He is not the whole planet and not wild nature; his domain is the worked land, the field a farmer hoes, the seed put down and the fertility that decides whether it rises. Against Yurugu, the pale fox who tore from the cosmic egg too soon and made a dry and solitary earth of disorder, Lebe is the earth reconciled and made to bear — the ground brought back into the covenant by a death and a rebirth.

A millet field awaiting the rain near Tireli, on the Bandiagara escarpment. The single annual rains decide the harvest, and the sowing rite of the earth-cult falls just before they come. — W.E.A. van Beek Collection, African Studies Centre Leiden, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

That rebirth is the teaching. Because Lebe is the one who died and rose as the earth-serpent, he binds death to the vegetal year and makes the binding legible. The millet dies each dry season and lies dead in the ground; with the rains it rises; a granary of seed is a store of the dead that will live. Lebe is the guarantor of that turn — the assurance, written into an ancestor’s own body, that what goes into the soil comes back up. His cult is fastened to two things at once: to place, and to migration. When the Dogon reached the escarpment they are said to have mixed the soil carried from Lebe’s Mandé tomb with the earth of the new country and made from the blend the first Lebe altar, so that the fertility of the abandoned homeland was carried bodily into the new one. From that founding altar every village took a portion, and each keeps its own, sacred earth worked into it, holding the land’s power to yield. The land the Dogon farm is thus not merely inherited but transplanted — a fertility with a genealogy.

The cult’s officiant is the Hogon, the senior priestly elder, in the tradition the oldest living direct descendant of the ancestor. He is the guardian of the purity of the soil, and his person is hedged with restriction accordingly: he presides over the agrarian rites and above all over the bulu, the great sowing festival that falls before the rains, in April or May, when the millet seed stored through the past year is given out to the cultivators. That seed is held to carry the spiritual essence of the grain, and the ceremony — offerings from the Hogon’s own fields joined to sacrifices on the Lebe altar — charges it with the vital force, the nyama, that a good harvest needs. The Hogon does not merely administer the cult; he is its most exposed instrument.

The most intimate image of the bond is nocturnal. The serpent Lebe is said to come to the Hogon at night and lick his body — cleansing the old priest, renewing him, passing life-force from the earth-ancestor into the man who serves him. The priest of the soil is himself continually remade by the soil he guards, licked clean by the snake that the first ancestor became. And the earth-power is knotted back to the water at the root: a sacrificial invocation recorded in Griaule’s material asks that Nommo and Lebe never cease to be, in the reported phrase, “the same good thing” — that the two never separate from the one state they share. The formula fuses the field to the flood, the seed to the ancestral water, and holds that the fertility the Hogon tends and the primordial moisture the Nommo carry are finally a single substance.

A Dogon granary at Yugo, its capped tower holding the stored millet. Seed kept from the year’s harvest is redistributed at the bulu before the rains. — W.E.A. van Beek Collection, African Studies Centre Leiden, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Lebe is one of four ordering cults through which the Dogon arrange their sacred life — the cult of Amma the creator; the cult of Lebe for the earth and the agrarian year; the Binu cult of the totemic founding ancestors who crossed into the immortal state without dying; and the Awa society of the masks, which governs the dead and the funerary rites. In that scheme Lebe carries the weight of the ground and the crop, the one office whose success or failure a village measures every single year in the height of its millet.

The altar itself is the cult made small and portable. A Lebe altar is a low built thing with the consecrated soil incorporated into its fabric — the earth of the ancestor’s first tomb carried forward and renewed generation by generation — and it is fed, in the ordinary round of village life, with the blood and millet of sacrifice offered by the Hogon and the Binu priest at the turning points of the farming year. What passes across it is not a favor begged from a distant power but the maintenance of a bond already struck: the ancestor gave his death to the ground so that the ground would give back its increase, and the sacrifice keeps the exchange in motion. The colored stones said to be Lebe’s rearranged bones pass, in the tradition, into the hands of the priests as sacred regalia, so that the officiant of the earth carries the ancestor’s remade body on his own person while the ancestor, by night, remakes his.

Reception: the record and the living cult

Lebe sits near the center of one of the most celebrated and most argued bodies of work in the history of ethnography. Griaule’s Conversations with Ogotemmêli and Dieterlen’s Le Renard pâle rendered the death of the first ancestor, the swallowing by the seventh Nommo, the colored stones, and the sacred altar-earth as parts of a single vast and internally consistent theology, and for decades that synthesis was the standard portrait of Dogon religion. It is now read with more caution than reverence. In his 1991 restudy in Current Anthropology, the Dutch anthropologist Walter van Beek reported that after long fieldwork among the Dogon he could not reproduce the elaborate esoteric system Griaule described — that much of the deep symbolism was not common knowledge, and that the parole claire, the “clear word” Griaule believed he had been given, looked in significant part like a co-construction between a determined ethnographer and a handful of exceptional elders. Griaule’s daughter Geneviève Calame-Griaule and others answered that van Beek had simply not been admitted to the guarded initiatory levels where such knowledge is kept, and van Beek returned to the quarrel in “Haunting Griaule” (2004). The specific charge does not dissolve the Lebe cult, whose altars and Hogon are plainly there to be seen; it falls on the dense interpretive scaffolding, the seventh-Nommo machinery and the reading of every stone as a sign, that the Griaule books hung upon it.

A separate and far louder claim grew from the same soil and should be kept clear of Lebe entirely. From a 1950 Griaule–Dieterlen paper on Dogon star-lore, the writer Robert Temple built The Sirius Mystery (1976), arguing that the Dogon preserved ancient knowledge of Sirius B, the invisible dwarf companion of the brightest star. That argument is widely judged spurious — most plausibly an echo of leading questions and outside contact folded back into Griaule’s own material, not indigenous astronomy — and it is a problem in the history of scholarship, not a fact about the Dogon. It belongs to the cosmogony’s reception, discussed with Amma and the people themselves; it has nothing to do with the earth-serpent or the sowing of millet.

What is not in question is that the cult is alive. The Dogon are a present people of the Bandiagara cliffs, and the office of the Hogon and the veneration of Lebe continue alongside Islam and Christianity, which many Dogon also hold. The escarpment where the earth-cult lives — the “Cliff of Bandiagara (Land of the Dogons)” — was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage list in 1989 as a mixed cultural and natural site, its terraced villages, granaries, and the older Tellem structures in the rock recognized together. The escarpment is old country: the Tellem built and buried in its caves between roughly the eleventh and fifteenth centuries, and the Dogon settled it after them. For decades before the recent troubles the cliff also drew a steady traffic of visitors to its mask dances and its terraced villages, an economy that laid its own pressure on a landscape the cult had always meant to hold for the seed and the dead. The living tradition older than the ethnography is discussed with the Dogon as a people and, for the ritual hub of Griaule’s fieldwork, with Sangha.

The recent history of the region bears on the cult only because it bears on the land and the people who keep it. Since about 2012 the Bandiagara country has been gravely disrupted by jihadist insurgency and by intercommunal violence between Dogon and Fulani communities, including the massacre at Ogossagou on 23 March 2019, in which around 160 Fulani villagers were killed. The fuller account of that conflict belongs with the people it has displaced and bereaved; here it is enough to record that the ground Lebe was carried to, and the villages that keep his altars, are among the places it has touched. The earth-ancestor’s promise is narrow and exact — that seed put into the soil will rise — and it is made in a country where the harvest, and much else, has lately been hard to be sure of.

→ Related: Amma · Nommo · Yurugu · Andumbulu · Bandiagara · Sanga · Songo · Ireli · The Dogon · The Tellem · The Bambara