Kotys

← Encyclopedia

She comes to us first not in a hymn but in a joke. An Athenian audience, sometime in the years around the Sicilian expedition, sat watching a comedy whose chorus took its name from her worshipers — men who dipped and dyed and danced by torchlight — and laughed at the most glittering politician of the city for keeping such company. The goddess at the center of that laughter was not Greek. She belonged to the Thracians across the northern sea, and almost everything the Greeks set down about her they set down to amuse or to scandalize. To find the goddess herself one has to read the laughter against its grain.

The name and the people who carried it

Kotys — also written Kotyto, Kotytto, Cotys, Cotytto — was a goddess of the Thracians, and the Greek and Roman authors who name her are unanimous on that single point even where they agree on little else. The earliest secure notice ties her to the Edonians, a Thracian people settled along the lower Strymon near Mount Pangaeus, in the gold-bearing country east of the Macedonian border. There she was honored, and from there her cult traveled south and west into the Greek world and beyond it.

The shape of her name is itself a fact worth dwelling on, because in the Thracian world a divine name and a royal name could be the same word. Kotys is one of the great names of the Odrysian dynasty, the line that built the first large Thracian state. Cotys I ruled the Odrysian kingdom in the early fourth century BCE, and the name recurs down the Odrysian and Sapaean houses for centuries, into the Roman period, borne by client-kings of Thrace. A name a goddess and a line of kings share is not a small thing. It marks her as a power of the first rank in the world that produced her — the sort of deity whose name a royal house would take to bind itself to her standing, in the way the kings of other peoples carried the names of their high gods. The Greeks who mocked her festival rarely paused over this; but the onomastic record carries its own quiet testimony, and it points to a goddess who mattered to the Thracians far more than the comic stage would suggest.

What that name meant is contested, and the honest course is to say so. One line of philological argument connects it to the Greek family of kotos, “rancor, spite,” and koteo, “to be angry” — a goddess of wrath or vehemence, perhaps, or a name borrowed into Greek and refashioned. Another, comparing further afield in the Indo-European field, would gloss the root as something like “war, slaughter.” Neither reading is secure, and both run the risk that besets all Thracian etymology: the language is known almost entirely from names and glosses, with no continuous texts to anchor a meaning. The name is real and old; its sense is a reconstruction, and a disputed one.

The geography of her worship is firmer than its meaning. She is fixed, by the oldest witness, among the Edonians of the lower Strymon, in the shadow of Pangaeus — a hard, gold-veined country that the Greeks regarded as the very edge of the wine-god’s wild homeland, and a region whose peoples kept the loud northern rites the Greeks both feared and imitated. From that base her cult moved. The notices report her taken up publicly at Corinth around 425 BCE, and privately at Athens about the same span — a fashionable import, a foreign goddess adopted by a circle of the curious and the well-to-do, much as other peoples’ powers were carried into the Greek cities along the trade routes of the Aegean. From the Greek world the cult reached, in time, as far as Italy and Sicily, where the Roman poets would find her waiting. Her movement is itself part of the record: a Thracian goddess does not become the subject of Athenian comedy and Roman satire unless her worship had genuinely crossed the sea, and the comedy and the satire, for all their distortion, are evidence that it had.

The night-festival and the goddess beneath the caricature

Her festival was the Kotyttia, and the texts agree that it was a thing of the night. It was kept, the sources say, with music and dance and torches, on hills and in the dark — pipes and cymbals and stringed instruments, the kind of loud, driving music the Greeks associated with the ecstatic cults of the north and east. Her worshipers were the baptai, the “dippers,” a name drawn from some rite of immersion or washing, or — on another reading preserved in the comic tradition — from the dyeing of garments steeped in costly purples and greens. The two readings are not as far apart as they look: a cult of dipping, of plunging cloth or body into water or dye, would have furnished both the purification the soberer sources mention and the ostentation the comic ones mocked. Which sense came first, and which the celebrants themselves would have recognized, cannot now be settled. The festival and the worshipers thus reach us already labeled, and the label is a Greek one — a name fastened on the cult from outside, and fastened, in the comic version, with a sneer.

Here the entry must slow down, because the picture the sources hand over is not a neutral description. It is, in its overwhelming bulk, a hostile and titillated construction. The Greek and Roman writers who give us the Kotyttia were not Thracian celebrants but outside observers and, more often, satirists — men reaching for a foreign night-cult as a figure for everything they wished to call excess. The festival is “riotous,” the rites “orgiastic,” the celebrants drunken, effeminate, obscene. Strip those adjectives away and what remains is sparse: a goddess of the Thracians, honored after dark, with music and dance and a rite of dipping. That much is tradition-internal, and it is almost all that can be said with confidence about the cult on its own terms. The Thracians left no scripture, no liturgy, no defense of their own worship; the night-festival of Kotys survives, like nearly the whole religion of Thrace, only in the words of those who looked in from outside, and in this case the outsiders were chiefly there to be entertained.

This is the load-bearing difficulty, and it is worth naming as a problem rather than solving by fiat. The reconstruction of Thracian religion depends almost entirely on Greek and Roman authors, fragmentary and filtered through their own categories; the Thracians themselves left no written corpus of their rites or their gods, as the modern surveys of the subject are careful to stress (the source-problem is general to the whole field). For most Thracian deities that means an interpretatio — a Greek name laid over a Thracian power. For Kotys it means something sharper. Her cult reaches us not merely translated but caricatured, played for laughs and for shock, by writers who found in a foreign goddess of the night a ready emblem of license. The “wild” and “drunken” Kotyttia is, to a degree that cannot be fully measured but cannot be ignored, an invention of her detractors. What the Thracians of Pangaeus actually did on her hills, in what spirit, to what end, is largely lost; the noise the sources make about it is loudest exactly where the evidence is thinnest.

One further caution belongs here, because it cuts against the grain of the whole literature. The Athenian cult that the comic poets attacked may not have been the Thracian cult at all. What a circle of fashionable Athenians did under Kotys’ name in the 410s — the dipping, the dyeing, the men dressed as the goddess — is the thing the Baptai lampooned, and an imported, urban, voluntary cult of curiosity-seekers is a very different creature from the festival kept on the hills of Pangaeus by the people whose goddess she was. The danger is to read the one back onto the other: to take the Athenian fad, already filtered through a satirist who meant to wound, as a transcript of Thracian worship. It is not. The reception and the original are two cults wearing one name, and the louder of them is the one furthest from its source.

Where she can be set beside her neighbors, she takes her place in a coherent sacred landscape rather than at its lurid edge. She belonged to the same northern world as the huntress Bendis, with whom the Athenians seem at times to have run her together, and as the ecstatic cult the Greeks knew through Dionysus — for the very tribe that honored Kotys, the Edonians, was also the setting of the Greek myth of Lycurgus and the coming of the wine-god. Some Greek writers reached further and equated her with Persephone, the queen of the dead and the seed. None of these equations is an identity; each is a Greek hand grasping for a familiar shape. But together they place her among the great goddesses of the Thracian and wider northern world — a power of the night and the festival, of the loud rite and perhaps of the fertile dark, met on her own hills before ever she was met on the Athenian stage.

The reception: comedy, satire, and the long afterlife of a scandal

If the Thracians left no account of Kotys, the Greeks and Romans left a great deal — and nearly all of it is reception, the goddess refracted through literatures that had their own quarrels to pursue. To read her afterlife is to watch a Thracian deity become, by stages, a Mediterranean byword.

The oldest surviving witness is the gravest. Aeschylus, in the Edonoi — the Edonians, the opening play of his lost Lycurgean tetralogy, which dramatized the Thracian king Lycurgus and his resistance to the new god — set her name in the mouth of his chorus. The lines survive because Strabo quoted them in the tenth book of his Geography, comparing the wild instruments of the northern rites; the chorus hails “Kotys among the Edonians” and those who hold the mountain-ranging music of pipe and bronze (Strabo, Geography 10.3; the text and the embedded fragment preserve the only direct early quotation that names her). In Aeschylus she is no joke. She stands in a tragedy about the terror and the power of an ecstatic god come among a people who would refuse him — named, invoked, treated as a real and formidable presence of the Thracian dark. That this earliest notice is tragic rather than comic is itself a corrective: before she was funny, she was awesome.

The comic frame arrives with Eupolis, the Athenian poet of Old Comedy who was Aristophanes’ great rival and sometime collaborator before the two fell out. Around 415 to 413 BCE, in the unsettled years after the Sicilian disaster, Eupolis staged the Baptai, the Dippers, named for Kotys’ worshipers, and the play has not survived. From the fragments and the later notices it appears to have skewered a fashionable Athenian set who had taken up the Thracian goddess as a private cult — the men who dipped and dyed and danced as she was danced for — with Alcibiades, the city’s most dazzling and dangerous figure, prominent among the targets. The comedy mocked the cult as a foreign affectation, its celebrants as soft and secretive men playing at a barbarian rite. A later tradition held that Alcibiades took his revenge by having Eupolis drowned at sea; the story is almost certainly a fiction, a too-neat literary justice, and is generally set aside by scholars — Britannica’s notice of the poet treats the career of Eupolis without crediting the drowning as fact. What the Baptai fixed, however, outlasted its author: the image of Kotys as the patroness of a clandestine, transgressive night-worship, a cult one named to insinuate.

That image the Romans inherited and hardened. By the time of the early empire “Cotytto” had become a stock figure of the secret and the scandalous. Horace named her among the rites of witchcraft in his Epodes; a poem of the Virgilian Catalepton invoked her in the same register; and the satirist Juvenal, in his second satire — a poem against hypocrisy and concealed vice — set her as the deity of furtive nocturnal gatherings, the “Cecropian Cotytto” to whom the baptai kept their rites by torchlight (Juvenal, Satires 2; the relevant lines name Cotytto and her dippers). For Juvenal she is no longer even particularly Thracian; she has become a Latin shorthand for the thing done in the dark and not spoken of by day. The goddess of a real people’s real festival had been emptied into a figure of speech.

This is the shape of her reception, and it is a cautionary one. The further from Thrace the sources travel, the more confident and the more lurid they grow; the closer to the Edonians one looks, the less there is to see. The single tragic fragment of Aeschylus, the lost comedy of Eupolis known only at second hand, the satirist’s sneer — these are the materials, and they were composed to move an audience, not to inform a historian. Set beside them is the mute counter-evidence: a royal name carried for centuries by the kings of the Odrysians, a cult located firmly among the Edonians of Pangaeus, a place in the company of Bendis and the ecstatic powers of the north. The modern recovery of Kotys is the patient work of weighing the second class of evidence against the first — of reading the comic and satiric record critically, as testimony about Greek and Roman anxieties at least as much as about Thracian rites, and of granting the goddess the standing her name among kings implies.

Marble votive relief of the Thracian goddess Bendis, met by her devotees, from the Piraeus, about 400–375 BCE — the kind of northern goddess the Athenians sometimes ran together with Kotys. British Museum. Marie-Lan Nguyen, via Wikimedia Commons. CC BY 2.5.

What is left, in the end, is a goddess seen almost wholly by lamplight not her own. The Greeks borrowed her and laughed; the Romans borrowed the laughter and forgot the goddess. Yet the name persisted where it had always been heaviest — on the lips of the Thracians, in the titles of their kings — long after the Athenian stage had finished with her. The Kotyttia on the hills of Pangaeus was kept by people who wrote nothing down and whose night belonged to them. The literature that survives is the literature of the lookers-on; the worship was someone else’s, and its quiet is the most honest thing the record preserves.

→ Related: Bendis · The Thracian Horseman · Derzelas · Gebeleizis · The Odrysians · The Getae · The Dacians · Dionysus · Sabazius · Artemis · Orpheus · Thrace · Sarmizegetusa Regia · Perperikon · Starosel · Tatul