Great Pyramid of Cholula (Tlachihualtepetl)

← Encyclopedia

From the plain of Puebla a green hill rises above the rooftops, conical, settled with grass and agave, a yellow-domed church on its summit catching the light off Popocatépetl and Iztaccíhuatl to the west. To the eye it is a hill. It is not a hill. It is Tlachihualtepetl — in Nahuatl, the made-by-hand mountain, the mountain built by men — and beneath its turf lie millions of cubic meters of adobe brick and rubble fill, the largest single structure ever raised by human hands measured by volume, a temple that grew across a thousand years and never, in any meaningful sense, stopped being a place of approach to the gods.

A mountain made by hand

The name fixes the paradox the place lives by. A tepetl is a mountain, and in central Mexican thought the mountain is the elementary sacred form: the dwelling of the rain-bringers, the hollow vessel of seed and water, the cosmic axis where the layered heavens meet the layered underworld. To name a structure tlachihualli — made, fashioned, manufactured — and then call it a tepetl is to declare that men have built a mountain — that the work of human hands has matched, in this one place, the work of the world’s own making. The great platform is the assertion in earth and brick that a people could raise the axis of the world where they chose to stand.

Its scale answers the claim. In its final form the base of the pyramid measures on the order of 400 to 450 meters on a side, and its bulk has been estimated at more than 4.45 million cubic meters — a volume that exceeds the Great Pyramid of Giza, though at roughly 66 meters its summit stands well below the Egyptian monument’s peak. The distinction matters and is often slurred: Cholula is not the tallest pyramid on earth but the largest, the one that holds the most. It spreads rather than soars. Where Giza is a knife of geometry, Tlachihualtepetl is a swelling of the ground, a mountain in the most literal architectural sense, and its squat enormity is exactly why the Spaniards who reached its foot in 1519 walked past it as terrain.

A thousand years of superimposition

No single generation built it. Tlachihualtepetl is the accreted work of many, raised the way Mesoamerican temples were characteristically renewed — not by demolition and replacement but by enclosure, each new structure encasing the one before it like nested shells, so that the pyramid is a stack of pyramids, a building that contains its own earlier selves. Occupation of the spot reaches back into the Late Formative, around 300 BCE; the first monumental construction followed soon after, and successive enlargements continued, with long pauses, into the Postclassic, spanning the centuries that elsewhere in the world ran from the age of the Greek philosophers through late antiquity and into the medieval era. Tunneling beneath the church, archaeologists have identified on the order of six superimposed major structures, of which only three have been studied in any depth; the others remain sealed inside the mass.

The phases that have been read carry their builders’ signatures. An early stage bears talud-tablero terracing in the manner radiating from Teotihuacan, the metropolis to the northwest whose architectural grammar set the standard for the Classic Mexican world. A later and grander stage, the structure sometimes called the Pyramid of Nine Stories with its tiered altar-platforms, is attributed to the Olmeca-Xicalanca, the dominant power at Cholula across much of the Classic and into the early Postclassic, roughly 200 to 900 CE — a people not to be confused with the much older Gulf-coast Olmec whose name they echo. Painted in the buried galleries are the murals that excavation famously recovered: a long frieze of larger-than-life figures drinking from vessels, the so-called Bebedores, and the patio precinct at the pyramid’s south foot, the Patio of the Altars, with its carved stelae and great inset stairways. The cultural layering is total. The monument carries within it Teotihuacano, Olmeca-Xicalanca, and Tolteca-Chichimeca hands, and across its life it sat within the wider current of Classic and Epiclassic central Mexico — the world of Teotihuacan and of the fortified hill-cities such as Xochicalco that flourished as that metropolis declined, and far older than the lava-buried round platform of Cuicuilco in the southern Basin of Mexico, the deepest antecedent of the valley’s pyramid-building.

The sanctuary of the Feathered Serpent

What the mass was for concentrates in a single cult. The great temple atop it was the central Mexican sanctuary of Quetzalcoatl, the Feathered Serpent — wind, morning star, breath of creation, patron of priesthood and rulership and the civilizing arts — and Cholula was, across the Postclassic, the supreme center of his worship. Around 1200 the Tolteca-Chichimeca, migrants who carried the prestige of fallen Tula, took the city and renamed the great hill Tlachihualtepetl; their conquest, their migration out of the ruin of Tollan, and their settlement of the surrounding Puebla-Tlaxcala plain are the matter of the Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca, the pictorial-and-alphabetic chronicle compiled at nearby Cuauhtinchan around the middle of the sixteenth century. In their telling and in the antique name of the city — Tollan Cholollan, Cholula the Tollan — the place laid claim to the inheritance of the Toltec capital, the toltecayotl, the condition of being civilized that every central Mexican polity coveted as the ground of legitimate rule.

That inheritance gave Cholula an authority that outran its arms. It became a pilgrimage center of the first rank, drawing devotees from across central Mexico to the shrine of the Feathered Serpent, and — more consequentially — a place of investiture. Rulers-elect of other polities traveled to Cholula to be confirmed in office before the god, their authority ratified by the Cholulan priesthood; the nose-piercing rites of accession that bound a lord to the cult of Quetzalcoatl carried, at Cholula, the sanction of the holiest version of that cult. The arrangement held even under the shadow of the great valley power downstream. When the Triple Alliance of the Mexica and their partners dominated the central highlands from Tenochtitlan, with its own twin-shrined Templo Mayor rising at the heart of the island capital, the Mexica princes were still formally anointed by a Cholulan priest. The sanctuary on the made-by-hand mountain conferred a legitimacy the largest empire in the land could not manufacture for itself — a religious sovereignty distinct from, and older than, military supremacy. Within the wider order of Nahua religion the place functioned as a kind of see: the seat from which the most authoritative form of the Feathered Serpent’s cult radiated outward.

A founding story attached to the mass itself. The Nahua remembered the great hill as the work of a giant — Xelhua, one of a generation of giants who had survived a world-destroying flood and who, having climbed to safety on a mountain, raised an artificial mountain on the plain so that no future deluge could drown them; the gods, offended at the reach of the building, were said to have scattered its makers. The legend reads the monument as a defense against catastrophe, an axis raised to hold the sky off the earth, and it locates the pyramid squarely within the cosmology that ordered the rest of the central Mexican world: a creation broken and remade across successive ages, sustained against collapse only by ceaseless ritual labor.

The overgrown mountain and the church above it

By the time the documentary history of the place turns sharp, the great temple was already old. Cholula remained a populous and sacred city into the sixteenth century, but the colossal pyramid itself had largely fallen from active maintenance — by some readings already by the thirteenth century — and earth and vegetation had begun to reclaim its terraces, so that by the era of the Conquest the bulk read as a green hill carrying a small shrine at its crown rather than as a stepped monument.

Into this the Spanish came. In October 1519 Hernán Cortés, marching inland toward Tenochtitlan with a large body of Tlaxcalteca allies — the warriors of the independent confederacy of Tlaxcala, bitter enemies of the Mexica and now bound to the invaders — entered Cholula, the second city of the highlands and a polity allied to the Mexica. The Spaniards arrived on the city’s edge on 25 October and entered before dawn on the 26th. Within days the encounter broke into slaughter. Cortés, claiming to have uncovered a plot to ambush his column, ordered a preemptive strike; the nobility of Cholula were seized in the temple courtyard and killed, and the Tlaxcalteca poured through the streets. The accounts diverge as accounts of such things do: Cortés’s secretary Francisco López de Gómara put the dead at some six thousand in a few hours; the Nahua testimony gathered a generation later under Bernardino de Sahagún in the Florentine Codex describes the killing of unarmed Cholulteca caught defenseless in the sacred precinct of the city they had trusted to their gods. The Cholula massacre — its scale contested, its pretext disputed across five centuries, its memory still openly fought over in the city’s commemorations — broke the spiritual capital of the Feathered Serpent as surely as the later siege would break the island capital. The pilgrims’ city that had anointed the lords of the valley was made an example on the road to the valley’s heart.

What followed at the great mound is the colonial superimposition rendered in stone. The smaller shrine at the summit was thrown down, and atop the buried mass of Tlachihualtepetl the Spanish raised a Catholic sanctuary, the Iglesia de Nuestra Señora de los Remedios, the Church of Our Lady of Remedies — its first fabric built in the later sixteenth century, rebuilt after earthquake damage, the present church consecrated in 1629, its interior worked in carved stone and gilded panel. The logic was the standard logic of the conquest of sacred space: the new faith planted on the high place of the old, the cross set where the temple had stood, the holiness of the site neither denied nor abandoned but claimed. It is the same gesture that set the Metropolitan Cathedral of Mexico City over the rubble of the Mexica sacred precinct in the former capital — the church built not beside the temple but on it, inheriting the mountain’s gravity for a different god.

And the mountain kept its gravity. The summit shrine of Our Lady of Remedies became, and remains, a pilgrimage destination drawing the faithful up the same slope their ancestors had climbed, its principal feast and its harvest-season devotions woven into a calendar that the older worship had shaped; the Virgin venerated on the high place is petitioned, as the rain-bringers of the mountain once were, for water and for the fields. Around her observances persist rites with deeper roots, and a Quetzalcoatl-themed observance gathers at the equinox at the foot of the pyramid. The made-by-hand mountain holds two devotions now, layered as its own construction is layered, the church standing where the temple stood on a mass that contains a thousand years of earlier temples. Excavation has tunneled the interior — beginning in 1931 under the direction of the architect Ignacio Marquina, the galleries driven steadily inward until by the mid-1950s some eight kilometers of tunnel laced the structure, mapping its successive shells while the church above continued, without interruption, to be a working place of prayer. The two claims to the high place have never resolved into one and have never had to. Both ascend the same hill.

Reading the mountain: sources and scholarship

The textual approach to Cholula runs through the central Nahua corpus and the colonial chronicles, read against the long archaeological record of the mass itself. The migration of the Tolteca-Chichimeca out of Tula and their seizure of Cholula are set down in the Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca, the mid-sixteenth-century pictorial chronicle of Cuauhtinchan, available in facsimile and study through the Wikipedia synopsis of the manuscript and its editions. The cosmological frame within which the sanctuary of the Feathered Serpent must be read — teotl and the cult of the teteoh, the ordering of the world by ritual debt — is reconstructed from the Nahua mystical and philosophical tradition: the parallel-column Nahuatl-Spanish encyclopedia compiled around 1577 by Bernardino de Sahagún with his Nahua co-authors at the Colegio de Santa Cruz de Tlatelolco, the Florentine Codex, whose oldest authoritative imagery is the Library of Congress digital manuscript; the song-corpus of the Cantares Mexicanos; and the moral oratory of the huehuetlahtolli. The earliest sustained English engagement with the Quetzalcoatl material, Daniel Garrison Brinton’s American Hero-Myths (1882), available as a public-domain scan at the Internet Archive, reads the Feathered Serpent through a now-superseded solar-mythology and racial-evolutionist frame and is used today as a historiographic specimen rather than an authority.

The competing accounts of the events of October 1519 are themselves a study in source criticism: the conquistador self-justification of Gómara and Cortés’s own letters set against the Indigenous testimony of the Florentine Codex and the Tlaxcalteca pictorial record, and against the modern reconstructions of the massacre and its disputed pretext. The archaeology proper begins in earnest with Marquina’s tunneling campaign of 1931 and the decades of work that followed it, recovering the Bebedores mural, the Patio of the Altars, and the buried construction sequence, and continuing into recent INAH excavation seasons that keep revising the count and dating of the superimposed phases. The cosmological reading of pyramid-as-sacred-mountain, the contested-site analysis of the church-over-temple superimposition, and the ethnography of living Nahua and Catholic devotion at the summit belong to a current scholarship — Carrasco, López Austin and López Luján, Plunket and Uruñuela on Cholula specifically — that remains in copyright and is treated here by pointer; the public-domain spine is the colonial chronicle and the early facsimile, read with the headnotes those mediated sources require.

The made-by-hand mountain refuses the tidy verdict its history seems to invite. It was raised to be the axis the world turned on, and it is one still: a mass of brick that swallowed its own earlier temples, a giant’s flood-defense in legend, the see of the Feathered Serpent whose blessing made the lords of the valley legitimate, the green hill the conquerors mistook for ground and then crowned with a church — and, on a feast morning, a slope full of people climbing toward a shrine, as they have climbed it for the better part of three thousand years, to ask the mountain for rain.

→ Related: Aztec Mexica Empire · Aztec Nahua Religion · Tenochtitlan · Templo Mayor · Tlaxcala · Xochicalco · Cuicuilco · Teotihuacan · Toltec · Olmec · Zapotec · Mixtec · Mexico City Metropolitan Cathedral