Eclecticism

← Encyclopedia

Eclecticism is the practice of selecting doctrines from several schools of thought rather than adhering to a single one. The word comes from the Greek eklektikos, “selective,” built on the verb eklegein, to pick out — and the choosing it names was, in its original setting, a deliberate method rather than a failure of nerve.

The term has an ancient pedigree. Diogenes Laertius, cataloguing the philosophers, reports that a certain Potamo of Alexandria founded what he called an eclectic school, gathering what pleased him from each of the existing traditions. Whether Potamo’s “school” was ever more than a label is unclear, and the report is brief; but the impulse it describes was widespread in the late Hellenistic world. By the first century BCE the rigid boundaries between Stoa, Academy, and Lyceum had grown porous, and many of the period’s most influential minds worked across them. Cicero drew freely on Stoic ethics, Academic skepticism, and Peripatetic argument as each suited his purpose; Antiochus of Ascalon argued that the major schools, rightly understood, had been saying much the same thing all along. Historians often describe the Middle Platonism out of which Neoplatonism later grew as eclectic in exactly this sense — Platonic at its core, but absorbing Stoic and Aristotelian material without apology.

The word did not stay neutral. To later critics, eclecticism came to mean borrowing without system, a thinker too timid or unoriginal to commit. That pejorative shadow has clung to the term ever since, which is why scholars now use it with some caution: it can describe a genuine method, or merely register a historian’s judgment that a body of thought lacks unity. In the nineteenth century the French philosopher Victor Cousin tried to reverse the verdict, making “eclecticism” the name of his own program — the claim that the true elements scattered across past systems could be gathered into one. The attempt did not outlast him by much.

The concept matters here chiefly for its bearing on syncretism, with which it is easily confused. The two are close but not identical. Eclecticism is a stance within philosophy — a way of choosing among doctrines, holding that truth is distributed and may be assembled. Syncretism is the broader fusion of whole religious and cultural systems, often gradual and unplanned, by which gods, rites, and stories merge. The late-antique world that produced the Hermetic writings, the Gnostic currents, and the figure of Hermes Trismegistus was saturated with both. The temptation is to treat every resemblance as evidence of a single underlying wisdom deliberately compiled. The more careful reading is that some of it was chosen and some of it simply happened — and that the line between the two is rarely as clean as either the ancient eclectics or their modern admirers have wished.

→ In the library: The Corpus Hermeticum (Mead) — I. Poemandres

→ Related: Neoplatonism · Gnosis · Hermes Trismegistus