Church of the Nativity

← Encyclopedia

The Church of the Nativity is a basilica in Bethlehem built over a cave that Christian tradition identifies as the place where Jesus was born. It is among the oldest churches anywhere to have remained in continuous use, and the cave beneath its chancel — the Grotto of the Nativity — has drawn pilgrims since before the building above it existed.

The veneration of the site is older than the structure. The second-century writer Justin Martyr, himself from the region, reports that Jesus was born in a cave near Bethlehem, and Origen a few decades later notes that the cave was locally shown to visitors. Whether this was the actual birthplace is beyond what the evidence can settle; what scholarship can establish is that the tradition fixing the spot is early and that the location has been treated as sacred for some eighteen centuries. The first church was commissioned under Constantine and his mother Helena and completed around 339, an octagonal sanctuary set directly over the grotto. That building was destroyed or heavily damaged in the sixth century and rebuilt under the emperor Justinian; the present basilica is in essence the Justinianic church, making its standing walls older than almost any other in continuous Christian worship.

The building survived the Persian invasion of 614 — by tradition because a mosaic on its façade depicted the Magi in Persian dress, and the invaders spared their own — and it was left largely intact through the centuries of Muslim rule and the Crusader kingdom, which used it for royal coronations. Its endurance is unusual: most of the great Constantinian foundations in the Holy Land were rebuilt or lost, while this one kept its late-antique fabric.

Custody of the church is shared, under a fragile arrangement, among the Greek Orthodox, Armenian Apostolic, and Roman Catholic communities, each holding defined rights to particular altars, hours, and tasks. The same status quo that governs the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem applies here, and disputes over it have at times turned violent. A silver star set in the floor of the grotto marks the traditional point of the birth; it bears a Latin inscription naming the place, and the lamps that hang above it are tended by the three communities in turn.

The site was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage list in 2012, the first listing entered under the name of Palestine. For the traditions that keep it, the question of what happened in the cave is not a historical one but a confessional one; for the historian, the church is a rare survival, a working sanctuary whose stones reach back to the first Christian centuries and whose claim upon the place reaches back further still.

→ Related: Archbasilica Of St John Lateran · Basilica Di Santa Maria Maggiore · Saint Sophia Cathedral