Carpocrates

← Encyclopedia

Carpocrates was a teacher active in Alexandria around the first half of the second century, named in the early Christian heresy-catalogues as the founder of the Carpocratians, one of the gnostic currents the church fathers wrote to refute. Almost nothing about him survives in his own words. What is known comes from those who set out to condemn the movement — Irenaeus first, then Clement of Alexandria, Hippolytus, and Epiphanius — so that the portrait reaching us is already a polemic, and the line between what the Carpocratians actually held and what their opponents accused them of is hard to draw with confidence.

The doctrine the sources attribute to him begins with a familiar gnostic premise: the world was not made by the highest God but by lesser powers, angels or rulers who fashioned the cosmos and now hold its inhabitants under their law. The soul, in this account, is a stranger here, descended from the unbegotten Father and caught in the order the world-makers built. Jesus, the Carpocratians were said to teach, was an ordinary man born to ordinary parents, distinguished only in that his soul, strong and pure, remembered where it had come from and so despised the powers that govern the world. What he did, any soul of equal strength could do — and several, on this view, had.

Bound to this was a doctrine of transmigration. The soul, they held, must pass through every kind of experience before it can be released from the cycle of rebirth; only when nothing is left undone is the debt to the world-rulers discharged and the soul free to ascend past them. From this the heresiologists drew the charge for which Carpocrates is best remembered — that the Carpocratians practised a deliberate libertinism, treating all conduct as permitted and even required. Whether the sect taught this in earnest, or whether the principle of exhausting all experience was read by hostile witnesses into a program of license, is exactly the kind of question the sources do not let us settle; modern scholarship treats the libertine reports with caution, since accusations of immorality were a standard weapon against rivals.

The movement was not large or long-lived, but it left traces. Irenaeus reports that the Carpocratians honoured images of Christ alongside Pythagoras, Plato, and Aristotle, ranking him among the philosophers rather than above them — a detail that places the group within the wider second-century traffic between Christian, Platonic, and Pythagorean ideas in Alexandria. A son, Epiphanes, is named as a teacher in his own right, though his historicity is disputed. What endures is less a body of writing than a position: that salvation turns on the soul’s recovered memory of its origin, and on its passage out from under the powers that made the world.

→ In the library: Mead — Fragments of a Faith Forgotten (1906)

→ Related: Cerinthus · Gnosis · Neoplatonism · Hermes Trismegistus