Bourges Cathedral

← Encyclopedia

Stand at the center of the nave at Bourges and look up, and the building does something no other great French Gothic church quite does: it climbs in steps. The outer aisle rises to a low vault, the inner aisle leaps far above it, and the central vessel goes higher still, so that the whole interior is one upward sweep of stone and glass with nothing to cross it. There is no transept. The arms that elsewhere reach out to make a Latin cross — at Reims, at Chartres, at Paris — are absent here, and the eye, finding no break, travels the length of the church in a single line and then up the graduated tiers toward the light. The Cathédrale Saint-Étienne in the central French city of Bourges is, by this one decision, unlike its famous siblings: a cathedral built as a pyramid laid against the sky.

The building and its plan

The cathedral is dedicated to Saint Stephen — Saint-Étienne, the first martyr — and serves as the seat of the Archbishop of Bourges, who carried in the Middle Ages the title of Primate of Aquitaine. The present building was begun around 1195, when Archbishop Henry de Sully resolved to replace the older Romanesque church with one in the new manner rising in the royal domain to the north. Work started at the east end, the chevet, as cathedral building usually did, so that the altar could be consecrated while the nave was still rising behind it. The lower church — the crypt that now carries the choir — was raised around 1200, and the choir above it was finished by 1214; the nave and the west front followed across the next decades, broadly complete in their main lines by the 1250s and the structure carried to its finished form in the second half of the century. The fabric incorporates, as its crypt, the masonry of the mid-eleventh-century cathedral that stood before it, so that the oldest stones in the building lie beneath the newest work. Since 1992 the cathedral has carried inscription on the UNESCO World Heritage list.

Its plan is famously austere. Where most great churches are cruciform, Bourges is a single great vessel — a long hall with no transept to interrupt it, ringed by double aisles that continue without a break into a double ambulatory curving around the choir in a horseshoe. From the outside the consequence is a building of unusual breadth and unbroken flank; from within, it is the graduated section that defines the experience. The main vessel stands roughly thirty-seven meters to the crown of its vault and about fifteen wide, its great arcade alone reaching some twenty meters before the triforium and clerestory begin. The inner aisle rises to about twenty-one meters — itself the height of a substantial church — and the outer aisle to about nine. Each ring of space steps down from the one within it, and the section so produced is the pyramid that gives Bourges its character: light enters at every level, falling not only from the clerestory far above but through the windows of both aisles, so that the interior is bright throughout rather than dim below and luminous only at the top.

This is held up by an audacious structural idea. Bourges dispenses with the gallery, or tribune, that earlier elevations used to brace the high vault, and carries the thrust outward instead through double flying buttresses on two levels — slender, steeply pitched arms of stone that spring across the aisle roofs to the outer piers. The steep pitch is the point: it sends the load of the vault and the press of the wind down a more direct line to the ground than the gentler flyers of contemporary churches, and it does so while leaving the walls free to open into glass. The same conception is already visible in the chevet, where the radiating buttresses and the stepped chapels announce, before one ever enters, the pyramidal logic that governs the whole. The two western towers are unequal — the result of centuries of repair more than of a single design. The north tower collapsed on the last day of 1506, a failure long feared, and was rebuilt over the following decades; the archbishop is said to have raised the money in part by granting, for a contribution, dispensation to eat butter in Lent, and the rebuilt shaft has been called the Butter Tower, the Tour de Beurre, ever since.

Doctrine taught in stone

The west front carries five deep portals, set beneath the towers and aligned with the five vessels of the interior — the nave and its four aisles — so that the basilica’s section is legible from the square before a visitor steps inside. The five doors are dedicated, north to south, to Saint William of Bourges, to the Virgin, to the Last Judgment at the center, to Saint Stephen the patron, and to Saint Ursinus, counted the first bishop of the city in the early Christian age. The northern portals suffered when the tower fell and were restored, but the central tympanum survived, and it is among the most complete carvings of the Last Judgment to come down from the thirteenth century.

It is read, like all such carvings, from the bottom up. In the lowest register the dead climb from their tombs at the trumpet’s call, lifting the lids of their graves — kings and bishops and ordinary people raised in the flesh. Above them the Archangel Michael holds the scales and weighs the souls, and at the balance the sorting happens: to one side the saved are gathered toward Abraham, who holds the small figures of the blessed gently in a fold of cloth, the bosom of Abraham of the parable; to the other the damned are driven by grinning devils toward the mouth of hell, carved as the gaping jaws of a beast — the Leviathan of scripture, swallowing the lost into a cauldron of torment. At the summit Christ sits enthroned in judgment, showing the wounds, flanked by angels bearing the instruments of the Passion, the whole crowned by ranks of the heavenly host. The carving is at once orderly and unsparing: the architecture of salvation set out with the clarity of a diagram, and the fate of the body rendered with a realism that leaves nothing abstract.

What the portal states the windows expand. The thirteenth-century glass of the ambulatory, made in the main between about 1215 and 1225 and surviving in remarkable completeness — most of the original program is still in place — is among the richest medieval glazing in France, ranked beside that of Chartres for the depth and variety of its color. Set low enough to be studied closely, the windows lay out the parables in sequence — the Good Samaritan, the Prodigal Son — each scene paired with its theological gloss, the events of the Gospel read beside the figures of the Old Testament that prefigure them; the lives of saints and martyrs; the Apocalypse; the prophets and apostles. At the base of many of the lights, the trades that paid for them are shown at work — the masons, the weavers, the carpenters, the water-carriers — so that the city’s labor is woven into the windows it bought. The whole was conceived to be read by a largely unlettered congregation: a Bible and a moral catechism set in light, to be deciphered from below in the slow time of the liturgy. For the cathedral was, and remains, first of all a working church — a seat of the bishop, a center of Christian worship, of pilgrimage, and of preaching, where the sculpture and the glass were not decoration but the visible body of the doctrine taught from the altar.

A later book of the stones

A separate interest attaches to the building, and to the medieval carving of Bourges generally, that has nothing to do with the bishop’s program. From the nineteenth century onward a current of esoteric writing came to hold that the Gothic cathedrals are not only what they appear — that beneath the Christian iconography of judgment and resurrection and the labors of the months lies a second, hidden teaching, the encoded doctrine of alchemy. On this reading the imagery of death and transformation, of bodies dissolved and remade, of the sorting of the pure from the base, repeats in stone the stages of the alchemical work — the operation by which, in the language of the Latin medieval tradition, the matter of the philosophers is broken down and exalted into the stone. The cathedral becomes, in this account, a book written for those with eyes to read it: the art gothique heard as argot-ique, the cant or secret tongue of the initiated.

The text that fixed this reading was Le Mystère des cathédrales, published in Paris in 1926 under the name Fulcanelli — an author who never appeared in person, whose identity is still disputed, and whose work reached print through his pupil and editor Eugène Canseliet, illustrated with plates by the painter Julien Champagne, the man most often identified behind the pseudonym. The book treats the cathedrals and certain secular buildings as monuments of hermetic teaching, decoding the sculpture of Notre-Dame de Paris, of Amiens, and others as deliberate registers of the Great Work. Bourges has its place in this literature, where attention falls less on the cathedral itself than on the nearby Hôtel Lallemant, a great merchant’s house built around 1500 by the Lallemant family, whose carved coffered ceiling and reliefs are read as a sustained alchemical statement worked into a private mansion. A second volume, Les Demeures philosophales, followed in 1930, extending the method to such domestic and civic monuments. The work became, within the modern hermetic revival, a founding text — a way of seeing that turned the whole built inheritance of medieval France into a cipher awaiting its key, and that placed Bourges among its exhibits.

Mainstream scholarship reads the same stones differently. To the historian of art and of the church, the iconography of Bourges is the standard iconography of its age: the Last Judgment is the Last Judgment of the liturgy and the sermon, the parable windows are catechesis, the labors of the months are the calendar of peasant work that adorns a hundred Romanesque and Gothic churches without a trace of hidden chemistry. The alchemical reading, on this view, is a layer of meaning laid over the building by later readers — a chapter in the history of esotericism and of the cathedrals’ reception, not a recovery of what their makers set out to say. The two accounts describe, stone for stone, the same west front and the same merchant’s ceiling; they part over what those carvings were made to mean — the one finding a bishop’s theology, the other a chemist’s secret — and the choice between them turns less on the stone than on what a reader brings to it.

The record and its readers

The documentary frame for the building is well established. The UNESCO World Heritage inscription of 1992 sets out the cathedral’s claim to outstanding value in exactly the terms used above — the unity of the design, the transept-less plan with its double aisles and double ambulatory, the pyramidal elevation carried on double flyers, the sculpture of the portals, and the thirteenth-century glass. The construction sequence and the principal measurements — the choir finished by 1214, the nave and front through the following decades, the nave vault near thirty-seven meters with the aisles stepping down beneath it — are gathered in the survey by Mark Cartwright at the World History Encyclopedia, and the iconographic program of portals and windows, together with the history of the crypt and the rebuilt north tower, is set out in the reference account at the New World Encyclopedia. The art-historical literature treats the west front and the choir glass as the standard catechesis of the thirteenth century, addressed to the eye of the worshipper.

The esoteric literature stands beside this as a distinct body of reading. Its governing text remains Le Mystère des cathédrales of 1926, anonymous under the name Fulcanelli, with its companion Les Demeures philosophales of 1930; the two are landmarks in the modern history of alchemical reception, and they are the source from which the alchemical reading of Bourges and of the Hôtel Lallemant descends. Its method is verbal as much as visual — the langue des oiseaux, a punning argot that hears art gothique as a cipher for argot itself — and it draws on medieval Latin compilations such as the Turba Philosophorum for the vocabulary in which the carvings are made to speak. What anchors Bourges in the record, though, is not a secret but a structure: the transept-less, pyramidal cross-section carried on double flying buttresses over double aisles — an experiment in distributing a great church’s thrust that gives it a singular place in the structural history of Gothic, and that neither reading has cause to dispute.

Bourges against Chartres

The building’s surest place is in the history of its own art, and there the comparison that matters is with Chartres. The two churches were begun within a few years of each other in the last decade of the twelfth century, and they are counted together among the first works of the High Gothic — yet they answer the central problem of the style, how to raise a wall of stone into something that reads as mostly light, in opposite ways. Chartres takes the cruciform plan with its broad transept, a clear three-part elevation of arcade, triforium, and clerestory at a single uniform aisle height, and a forest of equal flyers bracing a tall but conventional vessel. Bourges refuses the transept altogether, folds its mass into the stepped double aisles, runs a giant arcade up through the section so that the eye is carried unbroken to the vault, and braces the whole with the steep double flyers whose efficiency later builders studied. One church is a luminous box; the other is a luminous pyramid. Neither solution became the main line of French Gothic — the cathedrals that followed mostly took the Chartres path — and that is part of what makes Bourges singular: a road taken once, at full scale, and not taken again. The transept-less plan, the encircling double aisles, the five-portal west front with the dead rising at its center, and the single graduated climb of the interior remain, eight centuries on, the most complete statement of an idea its own age tried only here.

→ In the library: The Turba Philosophorum (Waite, 1896 — a medieval Latin alchemical compilation)

→ Related: Rouen Cathedral · Cathedral Of Our Lady Of Strasbourg · Salisbury Cathedral · Ulm Minster · Notre Dame De Chartres · Reims Cathedral · Cologne Cathedral · Notre Dame De Paris · Tournai Cathedral · Middle Ages · Christianity · Alchemy · Latin Medieval Alchemy · Esotericism · Modern Hermeticism Hermetic Revival