Benedict XII

← Encyclopedia

Benedict XII — born Jacques Fournier near Foix around 1285, pope from 1334 to his death in 1342 — was the third of the Avignon popes and the man who closed a quarrel about what the saved actually see after death. A Cistercian monk who rose to abbot and then bishop, he came to the papacy as a reformer with an inquisitor’s training, and his pontificate is remembered less for grand policy than for two things: the settling of a doctrine, and a register of interrogations that would become, six centuries later, one of the most-read documents of medieval village life.

The doctrinal question was not his own making. His predecessor, John XXII, had preached in his last years that the souls of the just do not behold God directly until the resurrection of the body at the end of time — that until then they rest in a lesser, deferred contemplation. The opinion caused alarm, because the Church had long held, without ever formally defining it, that the purified soul enjoys the vision of God at once. John retracted on his deathbed; the matter fell to his successor. In 1336 Benedict issued the constitution Benedictus Deus, which laid down that the souls of the blessed, once any purgation is complete, see the divine essence face to face, immediately and without intermediary, and that this vision is unending. The pronouncement gave the Beatific Vision its settled Catholic definition, and it has stood since.

Before Avignon, Fournier had served as bishop of Pamiers, where between 1318 and 1325 he conducted a meticulous inquisition into the surviving Cathars and other suspected heretics of the Pyrenean foothills. He kept unusually full records of what villagers said under questioning — about belief, sex, work, gossip, and the movement of sheep. That register, long an obscure item of canon-law history, became in the 1970s the basis of a celebrated study of the village of Montaillou, and Benedict is now known to many readers chiefly through the testimony he extracted rather than the doctrine he defined.

The two roles sit uneasily together for a modern eye, and the friction is worth naming rather than smoothing: the same precision of mind shows in both the careful theology and the careful interrogation. Contemporaries judged him austere and incorruptible, hard on the worldliness of the curia, slow and exacting in business. He began the great fortress-palace at Avignon and declined to return the papacy to Rome. He left no school and founded no order. What he left was a sentence about what the dead behold, fixed in the form the Church would keep, and a sheaf of confessions that outlived every political design of his reign.

→ Related: Conrad Of Marburg · Thomas A Kempis · Middle Ages