atheism

← Encyclopedia

Atheism is the position that no god or gods exist — or, on a broader and now common definition, simply the absence of belief in any deity. The two senses are not identical, and the difference matters: the first makes a claim about reality, the second describes only a state of the person who holds it. Much modern dispute over the word turns on which is meant.

The term itself is Greek in origin. Atheos meant godless, and in the ancient world it was an accusation before it was a self-description — leveled at those who denied the city’s gods or refused its rites, Socrates among them. Doubt about the gods is at least as old as belief in them. Greek thinkers such as the atomists argued that the world could be explained by matter in motion without divine governance; in India, the Cārvāka school denied an afterlife and the authority of the Vedas; strands of early Buddhist and Jain thought set aside a creator god entirely. What these had in common was not a shared doctrine but a willingness to do without one particular kind of explanation.

Atheism in the modern, deliberate sense took shape in early modern Europe, as the authority of revealed religion came under sustained pressure. The word began to be claimed rather than merely flung, and the Enlightenment gave it intellectual scaffolding: the demand that beliefs answer to evidence and argument, and the suspicion that the idea of God served human needs more than it described the cosmos. By the nineteenth century, atheism had allied itself with science, with critiques of religion as projection or as social instrument, and with secular politics. In the twentieth it became, in much of the world, an unremarkable option rather than a scandal.

It is worth keeping distinctions clear. Atheism is not agnosticism, which withholds judgment on what cannot be known; nor is it the same as secularism, the principle that public institutions stand apart from religion, though the two often travel together. Atheists differ sharply among themselves — some treat the nonexistence of God as a settled conclusion, others as the most reasonable working assumption, still others as a matter on which they simply find no compelling case either way.

Within a collection devoted to religious and esoteric thought, atheism marks the boundary the rest of the material is drawn against, and the steady counter-voice within it. The traditions gathered here largely assume an unseen order; atheism is the long-standing refusal of that assumption, or the demand that it earn its place. That refusal has rarely been mere absence. More often it has carried its own seriousness — an insistence that the world be taken as it is found, without appeal beyond it.

→ Related: Knowledge · Free Will · Soul · Christianity · Ancient Greece